It is time to have an honest discussion about Jason Spak’s suggestion that magnet schools should be closed, specifically PGH CAPA 6-12 (“To fix the school system, everyone must sacrifice,” Sept. 15). This is not about equity. This is about jealousy.

Yes, CAPA is a magnet program for those students who excel in the arts. CAPA is also a full day academic program. CAPA has been recognized as one of the best schools in the country by US News and World Report. The PA Department of Education, using the data it has collected, lists CAPA as one of the top ten schools in Pennsylvania. The US Department of Education has identified CAPA as a Blue Ribbon School. So, why would PPS close one of its most successful schools?

Mr. Spak states that students who come from privileged families have the upper hand because they can prepare for the audition using their privilege. No matter how much money one may have, if you can’t sing, dance, paint, act, creatively write, or play an instrument, you just can’t. That’s a simple fact. CAPA does work with students across the District to help them prepare for the audition and the application process.

Using Mr. Spak’s logic, to fix the problems of the rest of the District, they should close the schools that are working. By the way, there are other schools that are successful that are not magnets.

Advertise with us

How about taking a different approach? What is it that CAPA does well that can be used to support the programs at other schools? What happens in an academic class at CAPA that could happen elsewhere? They all use the same curricula.

To sacrifice a successful program because there are others that aren’t successful is irresponsible to those students with a different ability. Why isn’t he suggesting that PPS close those schools whose focus is special needs?

You don’t destroy what is successful to benefit the needs of others. That is inequitable.

Russell Kuehner

Ben Avon

The author was a teacher at CAPA for 30 years.