Transition off of coal-based steel-making grows jobs, despite claims to the contrary from Sens. Casey and Fetterman claim (“Environmental watchdog accuses Nippon Steel of “coal addiction,” May 31).

Just look to Ohio, where Cleveland-Cliffs is retaining 2,500 union jobs, adding 170 permanent jobs, and supporting 1,200 new building trades jobs for the first a new coal-free primary steel facility.

In fact, research from the Ohio River Valley Institute shows that maintaining “business as usual” will cause steelworking jobs in the Mon Valley to fall 30% due to outsourcing and automation. Conversely, switching to fossil-free steelmaking will increase jobs 27% to 43% to support increased demand and investment.

Cleaner steelmaking practices aren’t just better for the economy — they’re better for our health, too. Across the steel industry, industrial processes responsible for the most health-harming particle pollution — blast furnaces, coking, and basic oxygen furnaces — are all involved in coal-based primary steelmaking, and can be found in coal-based integrated steel plants, including the U.S. Steel facilities here in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

Here in Allegheny County 640 to 1,370 extra deaths occurred each year from 2020 - 2022. Our county has a 911-scale event every 2 years from air pollution. These deaths are attributed to particle pollution from burning fossil fuels, with the largest sources by far the facilities of the Mon Valley Works.

Regardless of how the acquisition pans out, whichever company ends up with U.S. Steel’s aging fleet of blast furnaces and coking operations will have a generational opportunity to improve public health county-wide, futureproof jobs, and reinvest in local communities by closing outdated facilities and developing modern, coal-free facilities that produce products for the future, not the past.

Matthew Mehalik

Pittsburgh

Mr. Mehalik is executive director of the Energy Innovation Center’s Breathe Project.