An article appearing on May 19, “A Healthy U.S. Economy’s Secret Ingredient: Immigrant Workers Needed to Fill Jobs,” made two very important points. One is that the American economy relative to other economies in the developed world is doing well. It is growing faster than others and with a lower rate of inflation than others.
The second point is that a principal reason for this is that immigration has reinforced a labor force that is otherwise underpopulated, and is becoming more so over time as fertility rates continue to decline and the proportion of retirees grows.
Perhaps we could get past the greatly misplaced criticisms of immigration and try to understand how much immigration in the past and the present have contributed to this country.
Politicians on the campaign trail, and above all their campaign advertisements, draw simplistic connections between macro-economic conditions and causation. First, no nation’s economy is self-contained. It is affected by international conditions such as war, shipping lags and costs, and production issues in other countries.
Second, even to the extent decision-makers have some control over economic conditions, it is the Federal Reserve that determines the discount rate that affects interest rates. President Reagan’s strategy to flush out the inflation at the outset of his administration resulted in the highest level of unemployment since the Great Depression. In other words, there is no single optimal strategy. Everything is a matter of trade-offs, and presidents are but one of many influences on how the economy adjusts to conditions.
Bert A. Rockman
Squirrel Hill




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.