As noted in recent PG commentaries, presidents from elite universities testifying in Congress were asked whether a hypothetical call for genocide would violate university codes of conduct. They responded with politically tone-deaf legalese, suggesting sanctions cannot be applied until hateful “speech” becomes “conduct” in inciting violence against others. Republicans on the committee were very critical and showed no understanding of the point being made.
To make that point more clear, I would have given the committee an example: Someone who falsely claims to have won an election is exercising a First amendment freedom of speech. No legal sanction would be possible for that speech alone.
Yet, if the person making false claims subsequently summons a mob to gather on the day Congress is to certify the election results and incites the mob by repeating the lies, stating they need to be willing to fight to save the country, instructs them to march to the Capitol, and watches on TV as they violently attack police, break into and deface the Capitol, then threaten the assembled Congress — and he does nothing to stop the mob despite the power to do so — those actions violate anyone’s code of conduct as well as American law.
Ken Perkins
North Squirrel Hill




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.