It is shocking that the United States Supreme Court has displayed its callous indifference to human life (“The Supreme Court’s absurd inhumanity: To preserve procedure, an innocent man must die,” June 12) on the heels of the infamous leaked draft of a “pro-life” opinion.
In any other setting, this degree of disregard for the life of Barry Jones would prove liability in a civil or criminal court of law. I write as a lawyer admitted to practice before the Supreme Court (and a former longtime resident of Oakland).
The leaked draft in the Mississippi abortion law case did not create mistrust in the court: It merely demonstrated why the court has lost the trust of Americans. The case of Shinn v. Martinez Rodriguez provides a strong reason why at least some drafts to be circulated among the justices ought to be released for public comment before the court announces its decision.
This would provide a needed challenge to the court to more diligently think through some decisions that would otherwise go down in history as simply bad jurisprudence. D.C. v. Heller, Citizens United and Shelby v. Holder to name three.
Bruce L. Wilder
New Orleans, La.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.