Democratic presidential candidate Mayor Pete Buttigieg has attacked candidate Sen. Elizabeth Warren over her proposals for universal health care, free public college tuition and school loan forgiveness. Much of these objections are because these programs would be universal, including the wealthy.
Does Mr. Buttigieg also seek to eliminate the universal nature of Social Security and Medicare, the very reason why these programs were able to pass and enjoy widespread support?
Free tuition would apply only to public colleges that wealthy students would be far less likely to attend and, consequently, also unlikely to take advantage of the program.
Universal health care does not necessarily mean that labor union membership, having negotiated better coverage in exchange for salary concessions, need abandon those plans. A universal system could be a floor, ensuring adequate coverage for all and better controlling costs. A private system could be preserved as a supplement for those who want to continue their current plans, not unlike how Medicare currently functions.
Myriad questions — such as how to fund these plans and whether they could pass in Congress and in what final form — surround these proposals. Nonetheless, there are answers to the objections being raised. If sufficiently laid out, the public might better understand the benefits of the programs themselves, as well as the investments in our population that would accrue.
Yes, it is fair to ask the wealthy to pay a bit more so that the nation as a whole might benefit from these programs. However, if we all share the burden, it’s also fair that we all be included in the advantages. To do otherwise would actually be contrary to Mr. Buttigieg’s professed desire to bring the country together and not exacerbate our current divisions.
Perhaps the most important question is, why begin your proposals from the middle and probably end up getting less than you might if you at least start with the bolder initiative in the first place?
David Wassel
White Oak





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.