Dan Grossman got it exactly right in his Aug. 7 Perspectives piece, “Don’t Trade Away Clean Air and Water,” on the proposed Pennsylvania budget bill. Every Pennsylvanian who has small children, who cares for elderly parents, who drinks water and breathes air should be outraged at this budget game-playing.

Here’s the toxic bargain they have struck: The generous lawmakers will levy a small oil and gas severance tax, yielding tax revenue amounting to a paltry 0.3 percent of the state’s budget. What does the oil and gas industry get in return for bearing this laughably small tax? It gets a gutted Department of Environmental Protection, with its permitting power severely weakened. It gets a politically appointed panel with the power to veto environmental safeguards. It gets environmental regulation by political influence, not by science and concern for the health and welfare of the citizens of our state.

Given the political power of the oil and gas industry in Pennsylvania, it’s perfectly clear who the real winners are here. Even if this small severance tax becomes law, the effective state total tax rate on oil and gas extraction will be far below the national average. Nationally, the average effective tax rate on oil and gas extraction is more than twice what the effective state tax rate will be even with the addition of this severance tax.

Robust environmental regulation should never be a budget bargaining chip. Surely there are better ways to raise the needed revenue.

Advertise with us

Gov. Tom Wolf, are you listening?

RICHARD D. ANKNEY

Squirrel Hill