When our state treasurer calls the state’s budget mess “extraordinary and without precedent,” Pennsylvanians take notice.
We notice because if there’s anything ordinary and precedented, it’s a summertime budget mess. That’s as much of a tradition hereabouts as ants at a picnic.
I called Treasurer Joe Torsella’s office to ask what makes this snafu different. Sure, America’s Largest Full-Time State Legislature has approved a $32 billion spending plan without any plan of how to pay for it, but that all seems merely a variation on an old theme. Right?
Not on your autographed picture of Charles Ponzi.
The two-word answer to what’s different this time is “a lot,” Treasury Department spokesman Mike Connolly said. The longer answer is we’ve gone into the red earlier and bigger than we ever have before.
“There are no more reserves,” Mr. Connolly said. “There’s no such thing anymore. The rainy day fund can’t even last one rainy day.”
Read More
While our commonwealth may have engaged in some crazy machinations in the past, “if the machinations are getting crazier, we have an obligation to note that,” he said.
We’re only six weeks into the fiscal year and Mr. Torsella already needed to grant a temporary, $750 million line of credit to keep state paychecks coming for the next couple of weeks. Unless the General Assembly does its job this month and makes hard funding choices, Mr. Torsella predicts the general fund balance will go negative in September and stay underwater for two-thirds of the fiscal year.
The state might need to borrow as much as $3 billion, he said. There’s no precedent for that.
Gone are the days when shame could compel action from the 253 lawmakers we send to Harrisburg. I’m thinking of a lovely moment in July 1992, during a similar impasse, when a 26-year-old clerk in the state Superior Court’s prothonotary office on Grant Avenue, having missed a couple of sorely needed paychecks, wrote a letter to his state rep in Shaler.
Given that he wasn’t being paid for his job only because the legislators weren’t doing theirs, Sean Cannon informed Rep. Richard Cessar that he’d be henceforth receiving Mr. Cannon’s rent and utility bills. Mr. Cannon likewise wrote his creditors that “due to the malicious and contemptible irresponsibility of my state representative and his colleagues … I have a serious cash-flow problem” and so his rep would be getting his bills.
Mr. Cessar, a Republican then in his 20th year in the Legislature, said of the young clerk, “This guy’s a little wacky.” (He is, which is why Mr. Cannon and I remain friends.)
Mr. Cessar had hopes of privatizing liquor stores to raise revenue — an old false hope even then — but the Legislature eventually found another way to balance the budget. Mr. Cessar never paid any of Mr. Cannon’s bills.
No longer is there that kind of pressure for budget action from disgruntled, unpaid state workers. In December 2009, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court sided with state workers’ unions and ruled that federal labor law trumped that part of the Pennsylvania Constitution that says an appropriation is needed before money can be paid from the treasury.
Without that pressure, the state went nine months past the June 30, 2015, deadline before enacting a budget. And here we are stuck in neutral once again.
The state Senate approved a revenue package last month that includes new taxes, including one on natural gas drilling. (Pennsylvania, host to the largest natural gas field in the U.S., is the only major energy-producing state without a state extraction tax.) But House Republicans, led by Speaker Mike Turzai of Marshall, have opposed any tax increases.
Trouble is, the House has yet to approve any other way to balance the budget, and isn’t scheduled to be back in session until Sept. 11. House Republican spokesman Steve Miskin said just because representatives aren’t talking on the House floor doesn’t mean they’re not talking. Mr. Turzai has been working the phones and hitting the gas pedal to find “an alternative that can pass the House,” Mr. Miskin said.
No other state sends as many full-time lawmakers to its capitol as Pennsylvania. Mr. Miskin readily agreed that with 151 House members rather than 203, it would be much easier to reach consensus. A constitutional amendment to shrink the House to 151 already has passed both the House and Senate once, but that needs to happen again before it would come to the voters for approval.
A smaller House also would save millions of dollars each year. That’s not billions, but does anyone still think paying more for this model is worth the money?
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.