While I don’t have a dog in this hunt, as I am a retired administrative law judge, I need to correct a few inaccurate statements in your editorial “Stacking the Deck?” (July 1).
You advocate eliminating administrative law judges and allowing cases involving individuals charged with misconduct to “be heard by real federal judges.” ALJ decisions can be appealed to the federal courts, so this is not an “either/or” situation.
You also state that “letting the same federal agencies make the rules, charge people with violating them and decide their guilt or innocence is a rejection of basic constitutional principles.” ALJs were created precisely to avoid this situation. The ALJ position was an outgrowth of the Administrative Procedure Act, which was created because regulatory agencies emanating from the New Deal programs had tremendous powers. The powers of investigator, prosecutor and adjudicator were all vested in the same agency and this was perceived to impede fair decision-making. ALJs were created to engage in evidentiary fact-finding and not be involved in any phase of a case other than hearing and deciding.
The APA created measures to insulate ALJs from agencies so that their evidentiary fact-finding would be free from coercion or influence. That’s why ALJ hearings are on the record and ALJs cannot be removed except by the Merit Systems Protection Board.
DAVE HATFIELD
Marshall
The writer was the acting chief judge for the Social Security Administration and chief administrative law judge for the Pittsburgh hearing office and the Seven Fields hearing office.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.