Your series “Vitals: Building a Healthier Pittsburgh” notices that many patients do not “welcome” the confusing array of health care choices some employers offer but fails to explain why (“Wrestling With Choices,” Dec. 7). The reason is simple — the interests of employers do not always coincide with the interests of their employees.

It works like this: At first, choice looks good because healthier employees can find a reduced benefit for a lower cost. But that simply means that less-healthy employees, who want and need better insurance benefits, are the only ones remaining in the better plans. Because they are sicker, claims costs for these plans go up.

This so-called death spiral can result in plans becoming utterly unaffordable, to the point that they collapse. The sickest employees then have no choice but to join the lower benefit coverage. As a result, the premiums of the low-cost plans begin to rise as well, so that employees now find themselves paying high costs for lower levels of benefits. Employers, through the magic words of “choice,” are simply transferring costs to their employees.

Unions and other professional organizations with specialists focusing on employee rather than employer interests have noticed these disadvantages and have often fought against them. Many United Steelworkers employers, for example, continue to offer a single plan of insurance coverage designed to allow all employees, including both the healthy and the sick, to spread the cost of medical care among all. Such programs reflect the paramount interest of all employees to share the costs of catastrophic illness and make sure that adequate benefits are available for those at the time that they need it. After all, that’s why they call it “insurance.”

Advertise with us

JOSEPH P. STULIGROSS

Associate General Counsel

United Steelworkers

Downtown