It’s surprising that the Post-Gazette is siding with big companies and their lawyers who want to hit low-wage workers with penalties up to $4,000 for supposedly voluntary wellness programs (“All Is Not Well,” Dec. 8 editorial).

It sounds great. A little bit of carrot and a little bit of stick and maybe employers can nudge workers to be healthier. But the problem is, there’s no evidence it works that way. In fact, the evidence is that these wellness penalties are just a tool for shifting costs to people with low wages and chronic diseases. That’s the conclusion of a 2013 study in the journal Health Affairs.

The $4,000 penalties that companies want to impose might be chump change for management folks, but for a low-wage worker, it’s enough to break the family budget. At that point, participating is no longer voluntary as federal law requires. It’s coerced.

Such arm-twisting might not matter if your life is perfect. But for someone with obesity and other health problems, it adds insult to injury. The wellness industry is preoccupied with obesity.

Advertise with us

Many of these programs are designed around a misguided notion of a one-size-fits-all body size that corresponds to a body mass index of 25. For most people with a history of severe obesity, that size will never fit. For people with an eating disorder it’s downright dangerous.

Wellness programs that genuinely promote good health don’t need threats and penalties to work.

TED KYLE

Upper St. Clair

The writer is chairman of the Obesity Action Coalition, a nonprofit organization dedicated to giving a voice to those affected by obesity and helping them toward better health.