The editorial board recently called on Congress to renew the wind Production Tax Credit, dubbing the PTC “a no-brainer” that can help curtail the “alarming” effects of climate change (“Invest in Renewables: Congress Should Revive the Production Tax Credit,” Nov. 18). Unfortunately, reviving the PTC is neither good policy nor an effective way to reduce carbon dioxide emissions.

First, wind energy is expensive and unreliable. Electricity generated from wind is 125 percent more expensive than natural gas and 90 percent more expensive than coal. And it only works when the wind is blowing, which is not necessarily when energy is needed most.

Moreover, the PTC is a massive wealth transfer from Pennsylvania taxpayers to out-of-state corporations. In 2012 alone, Pennsylvanians forked over $76 million more in tax dollars than wind producers in their state received in tax subsidies. Much of that money went to line the pockets of billionaires like Warren Buffett, who admits that wind facilities “don’t make sense without the tax credit.”

The PTC will also do little to combat climate change. The subsidy is a crucial “building block” of President Barack Obama’s plan to regulate carbon dioxide from power plants. However, that Environmental Protection Agency rule will reduce global carbon dioxide emissions by just 1.5 percent by 2050 — an effectively negligible impact.

Advertise with us

The facts are clear: The PTC promotes expensive energy, transfers wealth from Pennsylvania families to multinational corporations and fails to make a dent in climate change. Although the renewal of the tax credit has been approved by the House, the Senate should reject the PTC.

THOMAS PYLE

President

American Energy Alliance

Washington, D.C.