The theologian Karl Barth said that “conscience is the perfect interpreter of life.”
Maybe. But conscience is a costly and demanding mistress.
Liz Cheney has paid a price for letting conscience interpret her political life, and she will keep paying it.
Don’t get me wrong. I think she is both right and brave. But I’m not sure that those gleefully, or hopefully, anticipating her pending presidential run (including Ms. Cheney herself) fully understand the price.
John F. Kennedy wrote a book, Profiles in Courage, that was a tribute to eight United States senators (all men, of course) who took a single principled political stand that cost each one politically.
And each man is portrayed as a hero. The book is a love song to political courage.
But it’s not that simple, as Kennedy knew as well as anyone.
A politician who is so pure that he or she never compromises personal conviction, who fights every battle from a position or moral rectitude, will have trouble holding office and trouble getting anything done in office.
Woodrow Wilson, for example, knew he was right about the League of Nations, but because of his insistence that he knew best, and everyone should acknowledge this fact, lost the cause in the Senate. Harry Truman gave Gen. George Marshall credit for rebuilding Europe, knowing this would win the Senate.
Most good politicians know that courage exacts a certain payment, just as compromise does.
And most professional politicians, even the most noble of the breed, are not crazy about the idea of being political martyrs.
Our Founders, who pledged their lives, their fortunes and their sacred honor, did not long to be revolutionaries. They were not sanguine about risking their fortunes or lives. Courage was a last resort.
Lincoln did not want a civil war and could live with the thing he hated most — slavery — if it could be contained and he could hold the union together.
I don’t think Gerald Ford wanted to let Richard Nixon off the hook for his sins. And I think he well understood that pardoning Nixon would probably cost him the presidency. But Ford felt he had to do it to heal the country.
When professional politicians choose the right knowing they will pay, it is usually because they have exhausted all other options.
And this is as it should be.
One of the few politicians who told us the truth about taxes when he ran for president — Walter Mondale — got hammered by the voters. Ronald Reagan did what Mondale said would have to be done. He just didn’t say it. I bet Mondale was sorry he did.
Politicians are not priests. They are not moral leaders. Their job is to improve the community and the country — to help us progress, however proximate or haltingly.
Hence, better a Lyndon Johnson than a Jimmy Carter.
A great leader ought to have a moral compass, but he also needs the wisdom of the serpent.
And the ability to count.
I am not sure Carter, in LBJ’s place, could have passed the landmark civil rights legislation.
Professional politicians should only make absolute moral choices when the stakes are ultimate or penultimate and when there is no other way.
Notably, in A Man for All Seasons, Thomas More, the epitomic man of principle who faces loss of life as well as office, does not wish to be a martyr.
Even the saintly man invented by Robert Bolt was a practical politician who would have preferred an easier way out.
JFK understood. Though incredibly brave physically, he was not politically brave.
He admired idealists, but he was a total pragmatist, and sometimes cynic, himself.
One of the things President Kennedy could have done, if he’d lived, would have been to write a more nuanced and complex book about the practice of politics.
He actually wrote only part of Profiles, though he accepted a Pulitzer for it. (He conceived the idea, wrote the first and last chapters and created the architecture of the book. Aside from that, he hired, supervised and paid the real writer, Ted Sorensen.)
I don’t think the Profiles in Courage Award really reflects the thinking of the 35th president, either. It is mostly the Profiles in Courage From A Liberal Point of View Award and, too often, the Profiles in Liberal Posturing Award.
They got Rusty Bowers right this year. But an early recipient was Lowell Weicker, for raising taxes in Connecticut.
That took chutzpah, not courage
Other recipients are Nancy Pelosi and Barack Obama. Really?
Master politicians both. But brave?
The award has never gone to a conservative who stood up to the left — Pat Moynihan for facing down anti-Israel forces at U.N., for example. Or Solzhenitsyn for critiquing the West. Or Bob Casey, Sr., risking his political life to be a right-to-life Democrat.
Even members of the Democratic Party and of the left who stood up to corporate Democrats have never been honored. I am thinking of Rep. Marcy Kaptur and Citizen Ralph Nader warning of the destructive force of NAFTA. They spoke up and out and paid for it. And NAFTA wiped out middle America.
Maybe we should stop giving awards for doing what is right.
Liz Cheney is a hero. Genuinely.
Mr. Bowers, the former Arizona state House speaker, is an even greater hero.
He stood up to Donald Trump and his fake electors scheme personally — man-to-man.
Mr. Bowers then faced a state-wide mob. They came to his house.
He held firm. He did not yield.
But Mr. Bowers is now dead politically — drummed out of office and party, though he is precisely the kind of person we want governing.
And he can’t turn around and run for president. He’s just done.
Well, Democracy is worth it. It is worth the ultimate professional sacrifice of a serious politician.
Standing up to Mr. Trump is a noble way to go down.
But let’s be clear: Down it is.
Conscience has a cost.
Political courage, like civil disobedience, exacts a price that will be paid.
Integrity does not come cheap.
Politicians willing to risk it all for conviction often do lose it all.
In the end, they miss power; miss the chance to make a difference.
And we miss them.
For without power, the politician with a conscience is useless.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers (burriscolumn@gmail.com).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.