A friend called me the other day ex­cited about new sup­port for the Black Lives Mat­ter move­ment. He said he has not felt so hope­ful since the 1960s.

Former Pres­i­dent Barack Obama says he, too, is buoyed, es­pe­cially by a new gen­er­a­tion of young civil rights lead­ers.

There is great hope in this mo­ment. It is a move­ment and mo­ment that could change Amer­ica.

But there is also a cur­rent of ex­clu­sion and in­tol­er­ance afoot in Amer­ica to­day, and it is deeply trou­bling.

Advertise with us

Mar­tin Luther King Jr., and many oth­ers — An­drew Young, Ba­yard Rustin, Rosa Parks, to name a few — built a move­ment of broth­er­hood and mercy.

The ques­tion is: Will the im­pulse to build carry the day, or will the im­pulse to con­demn and de­stroy prove dom­i­nant and ir­re­sist­ible?

To suc­ceed, this new hu­man rights move­ment in Amer­ica must be one of di­a­logue, thought­ful­ness and fair­ness. Justice is not achiev­able by un­fair means. Progress to­ward a more just so­ci­ety is not pos­si­ble in a so­ci­ety over­come by what his­to­rian Rich­ard Hof­stad­ter called “the par­a­noid style in Amer­i­can pol­i­tics.”

When a cor­po­ra­tion bows to a Twit­ter mob with no re­gard for what the rac­ist la­bel means to the rep­u­ta­tion of a per­son or an in­sti­tu­tion, and with­out any cu­ri­os­ity about what the truth of the mat­ter might be, it vi­o­lates ev­ery stan­dard of fair­ness. But it also deals good­will, tol­er­ance and in­clu­sion a blow. It signs on to a new stan­dard — the pre­sump­tion of some sort of guilt for al­most all of us. And that is a wreck­ing ball.

Calling some­one a rac­ist in 2020 has the same force as call­ing some­one a com­mu­nist in the Joe McCarthy era in the 1950s. The ac­cu­sa­tion is the ev­i­dence; the la­bel is the proof and the pun­ish­ment. The mud sticks. Dem­a­gogues, char­la­tans and zeal­ots are al­lowed to ruin lives.

Advertise with us

They also triv­i­al­ize and ob­scure the very real and pro­found prob­lems of race that still ex­ist in our coun­try.

Every per­son in a po­si­tion of power and priv­i­lege must be con­stantly learn­ing about how to bet­ter wield that power and how his or her power af­fects those who have no power.

That’s a moral im­per­a­tive that is not pos­si­ble with­out good­will and di­a­logue.

It’s not pos­si­ble if we are busy smear­ing or can­cel­ing each other.

In the end, our col­lec­tive hope must rest with par­tic­u­lar ac­tions and sin­gle souls. Every Amer­i­can must strive, al­ways, to reach out to ev­ery fel­low Amer­i­can. We can­not pro­mote hu­man un­der­stand­ing if we can­not prac­tice it.

Advertise with us

There is a re­lated point to be made. It is that pol­i­tics must have lim­its. As the great An­drew Sul­li­van pointed out re­cently, the whole idea of lib­eral de­moc­racy is that there are vast realms of life that are or should be out­side the pur­view of ide­ol­ogy and po­lit­i­cal loy­alty. There are tran­scen­dent modes in hu­man life. Pol­i­tics ought not to be one on them.

We still need to be able to re­late to each other as hu­man be­ings.

And we need to pro­tect our pri­vate and in­ner lives.

When ev­ery­thing is sub­jected to the test of ide­ol­ogy, or a “cor­rect” pol­i­tics, you get to­tal­i­tar­i­an­ism, which is en­forced by ei­ther the state or the mob. Pri­vacy is de­stroyed. Ci­vil­ity van­ishes.

Fas­cism can come from the far right or the far left: Au­thor­i­tar­i­an­ism from the right, and purges of thought, peo­ple and speech from the left. Through most of my life in news­pa­per­ing, most of the bul­lies came from the far right. To­day, in Amer­ica, they come from the far left, though the fas­cist im­pulse is still from the far right in most of the world. But here, to­day, it is the “woke” who speak openly of si­lenc­ing po­ten­tial apos­tates.

Advertise with us

Let me tell you about a few of the tac­tics of the cur­rent woke mob: They bomb your e-mail with what can only be called hate speech. They twist your words and ac­tions. They make up things that you al­leg­edly said and did that you never said or did. They tar­get you and your fam­ily on so­cial me­dia. They bully those in their num­ber who seem not an­gry or de­struc­tive enough into sub­mis­sion. They leave anon­y­mous phone mes­sages dur­ing hours when they imag­ine you are not in (they hang up when you an­swer), and they say things like this: “I am so happy you are suf­fer­ing. No one de­serves it more than you. I want you to suf­fer more. I know that you will be fired soon and that your name will be be­smirched for­ever. This makes me very happy. I hope all this makes you sick and you die.”

This is not the be­hav­ior of a sol­dier in a hu­man rights move­ment.

This is the method of some­one who re­duces all peo­ple to cogs in an ide­o­log­i­cal strug­gle and sees not fel­low hu­man be­ings but ste­reo­types; peo­ple as sym­bols.

Yet the fu­ture of our demo­cratic ex­per­i­ment de­pends on our abil­ity to deal with each other as in­di­vid­ual, com­pli­cated, ir­re­duc­ible peo­ple, tran­scend­ing class, age, race and po­lit­i­cal and ide­o­log­i­cal loy­al­ties. In that de­moc­racy, we are each judged by the con­tent of our char­ac­ter.

I think the fu­ture of our hu­man­ity de­pends on this too.

Advertise with us

This is what Mr. Obama has long imag­ined and what Dr. King sought — a move­ment of love. It does not mean that so­ci­ety is trans- or post-ra­cial, but that the open hu­man heart can be. Heart can speak to heart, if we try.

Keith C. Bur­ris is ex­ec­u­tive ed­i­tor of the Post-Ga­zette, and vice pres­i­dent and ed­i­to­rial di­rec­tor of Block News­pa­pers (kbur­ris@post-ga­zette.com).