I was happy to read that Mayor Bill Peduto now admits there is a crime problem Downtown.

And also that he recognizes that it is not a simple matter. There is crime Downtown but not only crime.

“It's not simply a police issue,” the mayor said. “It is an issue that deals with mental health, homelessness and addiction.”

“It” is the matter of four Downtown stabbings in August, and at least one other instance in which a knife was pulled, the police came and an arrest was made — a scary moment that could have been another tragedy.

Advertise with us

There have been six stabbings Downtown so far this year — 81 in the city as a whole.

Crime is down in the city, generally. What worries a lot of people is that these Downtown stabbings have occurred in a short period, in a compact, contained area — basically the entertainment district, where there are also several churches that serve the poor. And they were senseless, even random.

This is subjective, but some in the Downtown community also believe that panhandling has increased and become more aggressive along parts of Sixth, Seventh and Liberty avenues.

Let's also not forget the killing of the Rev. Sheldon Stoudemire — who was shot to death through a security window after refusing a homeless man late-night entry to a shelter on the North Side. That was in July. “Sarge” Stoudemire had devoted much of his life to helping disadvantaged youth, the homeless and the poor.

And, yes, the incidents do all seem to involve the three factors the mayor named — homelessness, mental health and addiction.

Advertise with us

Many people living, working or worshipping Downtown are rattled. And justly so.

The mayor's initial response — to remind us of his own enlightenment, to cast aspersions on anyone who said there was a problem and to diminish the problem — was not helpful. His conversion to reality is.

So, now that we have the attention of the mayor and most other stakeholders, what do we do?

To begin, we need three things.

First, we need an outside, professional “best practices” evaluation of all the city's programs and procedures for dealing with the homeless, the mentally ill and the addicted.

Advertise with us

One person with knowledge of the situation told me that the city has many practices and programs and spends lots of money on this population, but little of it is effective or coordinated. I don't know if that is true or not. But I think we can find out if it is. Let's do an immediate program assessment.

Second, the city is reportedly considering donating land to build a year-round 70-bed shelter near the county jail. This idea should be quickly considered and examined and if it is as good a proposal as it strikes me as being — this seems to be the area where the need is, especially in the summer — get it done quickly.

Third, the city needs to talk this issue cluster — street crime, homelessness and addiction — through. We need a community conversation. The mayor and other city, county and regional leaders should convene a day-long town meeting with all the key players, plus homeless folk and their advocates. We cannot fix this overnight. But we can make it better quickly and then tackle root causes and the questions of model and approach. I would bet we need new versions of both.

Meanwhile, we have an increased police presence Downtown, and maybe we need to better enforce vagrancy and panhandling laws, as well as increasing available food, water and beds.

Those are hardly insurmountable short-range goals for a city with Pittsburgh's resources.

Advertise with us

But we should not kid ourselves. Finding, long term, the right models for dealing with people who are homeless, sick, addicted and often also pathologically angry and alone — broken in multiple ways — will not be at all easy. Indeed, we are likely to find there is no one great and elegant “answer.”

The Rev. Tom Hall, senior pastor at First Presbyterian Church Downtown, says that the fundamental need is volunteers “willing to walk with the poor across time,” knowing, he adds, that they may sometimes be socked in the jaw for doing so. People this desperate don't always heal and are not always grateful.

But, as in medicine, there are remedies and responses that are optimal, and remedies as well as responses that are useless or make the problem worse.

And, first, we need acknowledgment and diagnosis.

Almost 60 years ago, the great thinker and chronicler of city life, Jane Jacobs, wrote:

Advertise with us

“It may be that we have become so feckless as a people that we no longer care how things do work, but only what kind of quick, easy outer impression they give. If so, there is little hope for our cities or probably for much else in our society. But I do not think this is so.”

I do not think that it is so either.

Let's talk about what is happening in Downtown Pittsburgh. Let's put our heads together. Soon.

Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).