

























PHILADELPHIA — Post-Gazette reporter Ray Fittipaldo grades each position group and the coaching staff after the Steelers’ 19-16 loss to the Philadelphia Eagles.
Quarterbacks
The Steelers are still in playoff position, but it’s these types of performances from their 42-year-old quarterback that have the fan base clamoring for a young player to take the reins of the offense. Rodgers looks like he has aged years since the bye week.
The offense is incapable of being competitive early in games with him behind center. One week after the Cincinnati Bengals jumped out to a 17-0 lead against the Steelers, the Eagles — losers of seven in a row — got up 13-0 on them Sunday.
There have been far too many games this season when the offense has been non-competitive for three quarters only to make the score look closer because of garbage-time drives against prevent defenses. Rodgers has to find a way to get in sync earlier in games or this thing could go south real quick.
Grade: F
Running backs
Rodgers was the leading rusher with 29 yards on five scrambles. That’s all you need to know about the state of the Steelers’ running game.
Read More
Jaylen Warren had 28 yards and Rico Dowdle had 15.
During their 6-2 start, the Steelers fed off Warren and the running game, but it’s been nearly nonexistent in the past two games. In addition, the Eagles also prevented Warren and Dowdle from being effective as receivers out of the backfield.
Warren said the Eagles always had a defender in the flat to take away the short passes. That theoretically should open things up for the receivers, but you know that story all too well.
Grade: F
Receivers
It’s getting to the point where anything should be on the table with DK Metcalf.
Not only does he contribute nothing to the offense, but he commits undisciplined penalties on top of that.
After committing a second personal foul penalty in the third quarter, Metcalf was ejected. He finished the game with one catch for two yards on four targets.
It had to be some kind of feeling for Steelers general manager Omar Khan to watch his offense improve after his $30 million-per-year receiver went to the locker room.
Metcalf’s meltdown opened the door for Max Hurleman to play more, and he took full advantage. Hurleman had six catches for 61 yards and a touchdown in his NFL debut.
There was almost nothing positive to come out of this game, but at least the Steelers discovered they have another option for their struggling offense over the final seven games. Hurleman should start against the Denver Broncos on Friday. He made more contested catches in one game than Metcalf has all season.
Grade: F
Offensive line
The absence of left guard Mason McCormick, who dislocated his ankle last week versus the Bengals, was felt as the line was in disarray from the outset.
Rodgers was sacked five times. On the final one, a miscommunication allowed a free rusher. It’s one thing to get beat physically, but the inability to sort of communication issues is disappointing 10 games in.
Perhaps more distressing for the line was the lack of push in the run game. The Eagles dominated the Steelers at the line of scrimmage. The Steelers have invested far too much in this unit for them to play the way they have the past two weeks.
Grade: F
Defensive line
Cam Heyward had five tackles and a pass defended, but Derrick Harmon and Keeanu Benton did not provide much punch as run defenders or pass rushers. Like they did with their offensive line, the Steelers used high draft choices on Harmon and Benton, and those defensive linemen have to start becoming more impactful.
Grade: D
Linebackers
Alex Highsmith sacked Joe Milton III twice in the first few minutes of the game, but as soon as he suffered an ankle injury that knocked him out of the game, the pass rush disappeared.
Jack Sawyer tallied one more sack when he chased Milton out of bounds in the second half, but more pressure was needed against a young quarterback making only his second NFL start.
The Steelers blitzed on Saquon Barkley’s 38-yard touchdown run, but anytime a defense allows a running back to go untouched, it’s not a good look on the defenders on the second level of the defense.
Grade: C
Secondary
When a quarterback like Milton throws for a first down on third and 10 with the game on the line, you deserve to lose.
The kick in the gut was Milton made it look easy, playing pitch and catch to Darius Cooper for a first down that set up a field goal with 4:19 left that put the Eagles up by 10. Milton also completed passes on second and 18 and another on third and 13 earlier in the game. Both of those plays set up field goals for the Eagles, too.
Yes, the Eagles gained only 214 yards, but the Steelers failed to get off the field when they had the advantage. That’s inexcusable against an inexperienced QB.
Rookie safety Spears-Jennings took a bad angle and didn’t even get a hand on Barkley on his 38-yard touchdown run. At the very least, he has to slow Barkley down and keep him out of the end zone. That was the only touchdown the Eagles scored.
Grade: F
Special teams
Searching for a spark in their return game, the Steelers brought up Hurleman from the practice squad to replace Kaden Wetjen. Other than misplaying one kickoff, Hurleman did plenty to earn more playing time as a returner. He averaged 12 yards on three punt returns and almost broke off a long return on the opening kickoff.
Backup cornerback Brandin Echols ran out of bounds on a punt, giving the Eagles a free five yards. In a low-scoring game, those types of mistakes can haunt you. The Eagles started near midfield as a result and kicked a field goal.
The final margin of defeat? Three points.
Grade: D
Coaching
The decision on the first series of the game to run a stretch play on fourth and 1 rather than a sneak with Pat Freiermuth was odd to say the least. Why not just punt it away and pin an inexperienced quarterback deep in his own territory? Instead, Mike McCarthy handed the Eagles three points.
It also was a complete show of disrespect to the Eagles, who used the momentum to build an early lead they would never relinquish.
New coaching staffs love to play their draft picks, but rookies make mistakes. Spears-Jennings made a major mistake on Barkley’s touchdown run. Undrafted rookie defensive lineman Kevin Jobity Jr. was in the game often as a pass rusher on third downs early in the game. Yes, he’s known for his pass-rushing abilities, but it seemed forced when highly-drafted players such as Harmon, Benton and Heyward were not in the game.
Then on the first series of the second half, after Carson Bruner recovered a fumble on the opening kickoff, McCarthy trotted out Rico Dowdle at running back. Warren has been by far the team’s best player all season, and he deserved to start the second half.
He had only 11 touches all game to Dowdle’s nine. The Eagles took Warren out of the game. Steelers coaches needed to find a way to scheme touches and opportunities for their best player.
Grade: F






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.