We tell ourselves stories in order to live,” wrote Joan Didion, in her book “The White Album.”
I used to think this sounded grand but pompous.
Now I think it is an understatement.
Didion went on to say: “... We look for the sermon in the suicide, for the social or moral lesson in the murder of five. We interpret what we see, select the most workable of the multiple choices. We live entirely, especially if we are writers, by the imposition of a narrative line upon disparate images ...”
Yep. Disparate images and disparate facts.
Not long ago I accompanied my brother and his oldest friend on a brief tour of their college alma mater, near Wheeling, W.Va. The gap between the physical ordinariness of the place and the vividness and power of their memories was a chasm.
Read More
Big stuff happened at that place. That's what they remembered. And funny stuff. And lives were set on certain courses.
That's how memory works — the imposition of the narrative line.
A few years back, on a nostalgia walk and drive around in my home town in Ohio, a trip I never tire of taking, my youngest son told me that he was jealous of the sheer number of my childhood memories.
I asked him what he meant. He said: “My generation just doesn't have as much experience as yours. Not as many things happened to us.”
Could this be true?
We talked about the ways in which millennials have been cocooned — by electronics, social media, protective parents, the suburbs, etc. Maybe less did happen. Maybe the world is less open today.
But didn't my generation feel less experienced in the world than our parents and grandparents?
Every generation longs to create, and connect with, memory, sometimes even if the connection is not strictly true.
My mother was American but of Irish heritage. And this heritage was everything to her. It also meant that most of her stories were enhanced, and then polished. Narratives and punchlines were imposed.
Additionally, the stories had to have congruity with whatever agenda she was pursuing at that moment. When no longer useful to her purpose, she would abandon a storyline, though not the raw material, like an old car that has ceased to be reliable.
All humans cling to memory, enhance memory and create myth. It's how we are wired. Nations do it, too, if they truly are nations. If they somehow cohere.
If we in the United States did not believe, at least to some extent, in American exceptionalism, we would not be Americans any more.
One of the things Ronald Reagan did as president was to restore the language of national myth. We became, again, “the shining city on a hill.”
In the 1970s, some Americans thought we could live without myth and the oratory born of it. Tell that to Lincoln at Gettysburg.
Something I think is missing in President Donald Trump and, thus far, in all the Democrats who would replace him, is an ability to recall the collective memory of the American vision in speech and to connect with it. Barack Obama could do that. Franklin Roosevelt could. No one in the current field has really even tried.
And that's too bad, because memory and myth have the power to bind.
Martin Luther King Jr. connected his dream to the republic’s foundational principles.
A few days ago, I made another memory trip with an old friend from grad school at Pitt. It was the same deal as my brother and his pal: My friend recounted wild things we'd done and witty things I'd said, most of which I did not recall at all and many of which I doubt happened. Perfectly ordinary buildings we lived in and the often ugly buildings we worked in were elevated to mythic level. Wilson's Drug Store became a shrine.
We were happy to find, in the shadow of a modern hospital, at the end of a dirty alleyway, the remains of the old 7-Eleven where, years gone by, we bought coffee and beer. Eureka! The lost ark.
National memory works the same way as the memory of friendship and family. It is often enhanced; it can be dangerously false; it can unify and heal. That is why why we must teach history and examine both the depth and the delusion inherent in collective recollection.
On the same day of our Pittsburgh nostalgia tour, we saw a powerful film — “The Last Black Man in San Francisco,” which on one level is about gentrification, but on a deeper level is about a young man's longing for family and home, and his willingness to cross into delusion to find both. He is fueled by the need for memory. He imposes a narrative line. He creates history.
Why do we tell ourselves stories?
It's as Didion said: To create order out of chaos. To create a map for the journey. And there is something else, something even more elusive. We tell ourselves stories for the sheer pleasure that comes from the telling and the retelling.
Isak Dinesen, who wrote exquisite stories, said: “All sorrows can be borne if you put them into a story or tell a story about them.”
And all joys, large and small, are magnified.
Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.