A few days ago my wife and I drove to Washington, Pa., for a sentimental walkabout.

“Little Washington” was where we began our family.

I was already teaching political science at Washington & Jefferson — struggling to connect the high concepts of grad school with teaching freshmen how a bill becomes law — when we married. Some 36 years ago I was coming out of a classroom in Old Main when a student ran up to say my wife was at the hospital, in labor. (Thereupon commenced several confused dashes up and down the long staircase.)

We found the campus quiet and locked up in the summer of 2019, but looking handsome and well maintained. W&J is distinctive. It has long managed to strike a smart balance of liberal education and professional preparation for its students.

Advertise with us

We walked from downtown to campus, as I often did years ago. Along the way we met a remarkably cheerful homeless man who had set up HQ in the entrance alcove of First Presbyterian Church, essentially on campus. I recall listening to a baccalaureate address or two there. W&J was a Presbyterian school back, way back, in the day.

Just a few days later I read of the death of Howard Burnett, who was president of the school when I taught there.

Mr. Burnett, who led W&J for almost three decades, really stabilized and strengthened the school, financially and in every other way. He and his late first wife Barbara were also extraordinarily kind to a young couple almost totally clueless about almost everything, In fact, it was he who found us campus-owned housing (a block behind the president’s residence) when we needed more room for our child. (We came home from a party at the big yellow house once and freaked out when we found that our sitter — one of my students whom we called Dano — had put the baby to sleep on his back. We’d read in some ersatz baby book that babies should always be placed on their stomachs. Lord, we were dumb.)

But mostly what I recall about Mr. Burnett was that he ruled the college as a monarch (albeit a benign one), that he had little patience for academic pretense, and that he suffered fools not at all.

The man who lasted 28 years at that good institution would not last 28 days today.

Advertise with us

Howard Burnett was a get to-the-point, results-based sort of guy. He clearly valued intellect — he was a Rhodes scholar and held a Ph.D. — but not intellect devoid of usefulness or divorced from life. I know he respected individual faculty members, but it seemed to me he thought of faculty gatherings as playpen calls.

He was one of a kind. And it’s sad to me that most college and university presidents today are interchangeable — mediocre clones of each other.

I have also been thinking about Charles Krauthammer, on the first anniversary of his death. He was the finest political essayist of his generation, and for the same reason that Mr. Burnett was a good college president — he was his own role model. He didn’t fit the mold. His career would not be possible now.

Krauthammer saw further into the distance than most pundits wish to imagine: He viewed all certitude with suspicion. He saw history as tragic, not progressive, and certainly not redemptive. He respected fate. “It’s all an accident,” he once said, good fortune and bad.

After the accident that left him wheelchair-bound for life, two books were found among Krauthammer’s belongings, poolside: a neurology textbook and “Man’s Fate” by Andre Malraux.

Advertise with us

Charles Krauthammer was the closest thing to Walter Lippmann in his generation. He was a public philosopher. One read him more to follow his thought patterns than to assent to his conclusions. But perhaps his greatest contribution was his empiricism. He looked at outcomes more closely than words. He was a physician, after all. “If the treatment is killing your patient,” he said, “you stop the treatment.”

Even Krauthammer could not maintain the Olympian independence of a Lippmann or an Orwell. But he was an essentially free man.

There are three tests of the independent spirit in public life:

First, primary loyalty to principle, persons and institutions over factions and -isms.

Second, respect for empirical findings: Is the treatment — for the poor, or the Republicans, or the universities — working?

Advertise with us

And, third, willingness to find one’s own path, to the let chips fall where they might, even to offend.

I think of William F. Buckley bucking the right he’d helped create by advocating legalization of marijuana or questioning the Iraq war. Or Barry Goldwater saying gays have as much right to be in the military as anyone else, maybe more if they are skilled marksmen or aviators.

Who has the standing to stand alone today?

After the panderfest of the Democratic debates, I think of Churchill: “I have nothing to offer but blood, toil, tears and sweat.”

I would have loved it if any one of the candidates had said: I am not going to promise you a damn thing — nothing but my labors and my probity.

Advertise with us

Howie Burnett would have said something like that. So would Charles Krauthammer.

Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).