Oberlin College has been disgraced, not so much by its loss of a landmark civil case brought against it by a local bakery, or even by the size of the award against it — $44 million — as by its institutional participation in a slander.

Calling someone a racist has become the most scurrilous but also most impossible to refute libel of our time. One has only to say it; one need not prove it. The damage is done.

Like calling someone a communist in the 1950s, calling someone a racist should be considered libel per se.

What happened at Oberlin was not just name-calling, however. It was an institution, as an institution, endorsing and abetting the libel against another institution, albeit a much smaller one.

Advertise with us

This cost Oberlin, big time. But what is damning and chilling to me is that Oberlin, again as an institution, has shown no remorse. It is an institution of higher learning that seems not to have learned.

What in the world possessed Oberlin’s leaders to enter the culture wars? Even if, as individuals, they had a side in this local spat in those wars? Did they not see that Oberlin has a duty to stand apart from such conflicts?

There are two things a college or university should be, above all else, and beyond all dispute: First, it should be a bastion of free speech and free thought. Second, it should stand above partisan politics.

While every kind of political speech and assembly should be welcome on campus, the college or university itself should not sponsor or endorse any politics.

The core political, and human, values of the university are intellectual freedom and intellectual rigor.

Advertise with us

But too many of our institutions of higher leaning have forgotten this.

A few months back I had a conversation with a former colleague from my days in college teaching. This individual, very far from a reactionary, told me that he was tired and discouraged. “By the kids?” I asked. No, he said, the kids are great. He was discouraged by the dreary political correctness and intellectual homogeneity of the campus today.

The law schools, he told me, are worse than the liberal arts colleges.

What a curious, sad, indeed tragic, development.

And yet that is the reality of the liberal intolerance at Oberlin and on so many other campuses (it is the very opposite of liberal, of course.)

Advertise with us

And this closing of the academic mind is now deeply set. Last week, we had the case of Kyle Kashuv — the kid from Parkland High school who favors gun rights. He said and wrote some blatantly and bizarre racist and even anti-Semitic things (he is Jewish) when he was 16. They, of course, (it is the nature of our age) have now come to light. They are revolting. They are also, of course, deemed unforgivable.

Even though the young man says he now renounces those things he said and wrote, that he is a different person who thinks differently than when he was 16, and that he wrote those things as a kind of teen dare — among boys who were all trying to be more outrageous than the next — there is to be no forgiveness here.

This is a shame. For isn’t this what we hope for a bigot? Redemption? Don’t we want him to learn and to change? And don’t we have to believe that this is possible?

Should not our institutions of higher learning be places where people can learn and where minds do change?

One would expect Harvard to be such a place.

Advertise with us

Kyle Kashuv grew. A crackpot grew into a thoughtful man. And yet his past stupidity is apparently bound to stand as a permanent rebuke and nullification.

Growth is the point of intellectual life. The life of the mind is the ultimate justification of the academy. Yet, on the modern-day campus, there is a malignant convergence of ideology, political correctness, and virtue signaling. And this stifles free thought, makes growth difficult, and, ultimately stifles the individual.

I cannot help but wonder if Kyle Kashuv would be forgiven and given a second chance were he of the left and not the right; for gun control rather than pro-Second Amendment.

What bothers me is my sense that this young man is being stifled, silenced.

There are two great crises of our day. One is practical and material — it is the crisis of the earth. It is the crisis of our water and air and animal life and our mismanagement of our resources and inability to live in some sort of sync with nature.

Advertise with us

The other is intellectual. It is the crisis of free thought — the bearing down of gigantic and corporate and social forces on the individual conscience and mind.

The college and university should be the haven for the unrepentant individual, thinking his own thoughts.

Instead, too many campuses today are places where uniformity and ascent to received wisdom are required and the person is crushed.

Oberlin tried to crush the owners of a local bakery and Harvard would end the academic career of a promising young man before it starts.

“Civilization,” Charles Krauthammer once wrote, “hangs on the Kantian principle that human beings are to be treated as ends and not means.”

Advertise with us

We need the dissenters to keep dissenting and remind our universities that human beings are the ends and point of it all.

Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).