It is age-old political wisdom: A politician who is likable, whom even his adversaries kind of like, has an advantage.

Ronald Reagan was perhaps the classic example.

Granted, his ideological enemies hated him. But few who covered him in the press, and few who worked with him in Washington, did. With his Irish charm and quick wit, he was a hard man to hate. He was at ease with almost anyone, because he was at ease with himself.

This was true, on the Democratic side, of Hubert Humphrey. Tough to hate a guy that earnest, decent and hardworking.

Advertise with us

Likability — some people call it “the beer test,” as in “would you like to have a beer with that candidate?” — matters.

But the beer test is more than being likable. It also has to do with substantiality. You might have that beer because the person impresses or interests you, even though you do not totally buy his or her politics.

I have no doubt that the beer test made the difference for Donald Trump in 2016 — just enough difference with just enough people, though Mr. Trump does not drink.

I don’t think this cadre of swing voters found Mr. Trump likable so much as intriguing, new and possibly worth a roll of the dice.

And they found, many of them, Hillary Clinton to be profoundly uninteresting, shopworn — not someone they’d particularly want to sit down and have a beer with.

Advertise with us

When I look at the ever-lengthening Democratic presidential field, I am struck by the lack of basic human appeal: likability or heft. How many of the 20-odd Democratic candidates would you like to meet, never mind talk with?

Some do indeed seem substantial — Liz Warren and Bernie Sanders, for example. Both are strong, fearless and articulate. But would you want to have a beer with either?

One does not want to be lectured to over a beer.

Both Bernie and Liz are scolds.

Would you want to join Beto O’Rourke for a teeth-cleaning or a massage?

Advertise with us

How quickly “woke” became precious.

But maybe Beto will be born yet again.

I think the press is in love with Mayor Pete Buttigieg of South Bend because he seems both substantial and likable — something amazingly rare for a politician. Thus, an exception, like Reagan or Jack Kennedy, proves the rule: Politicians are phonies and bores.

Mayor Pete seems really smart and really down to earth. Or good at mimicking both.

Who would not want to have a beer with him, in part to find out if he’s for real.

Advertise with us

The great novelist Isabel Allende once said that the secret to seducing a man is simple. You say: Tell me your story.

One looks at most of the Democratic candidates — Kamala Harris, for example, or Cory Booker — and wonders if they are at all interested in romancing the American electorate.

Who wants to have a beer with someone supremely uninterested in any story but his own?

At least with Beto and Pete you get the sense of someone with a capacity to listen.

And I will say this for Donald Trump and Joe Biden: Both seem interested in people. Not The People, or Humankind, but people. Mr. Trump, a New York billionaire, somehow connected with the dispossessed of middle Pennsylvania and Appalachia. Mr. Biden, whatever happens in 2020, is seen by many Americans as one of us.

Advertise with us

If I had a beer with Mayor Pete, I would ask him: What’s really the plan? Are you running for 2020? Or for veep? Alright, you are brilliant. But do you seriously feel qualified to be president at 37, after a few years running a small city?

I would ask Mr. Trump, over coffee, what is the most important thing you have learned?

I would ask Mr. Biden, another teetotaler, how do you plan to bring us together? And how do you plan, at your age, to stay fit, physically and mentally, in the hardest job there is?

But I would cross the street to have a beer with any of those men, or Stacey Abrams, if she runs for president or veep.

And there are many candidates for president I would not cross the street to meet.

Advertise with us

In fact there are some who, if they were on my side of the street, I would cross traffic to escape.

“You vote for the man,” Sen. Eugene McCarthy once told the writer and critic Leon Wieseltier as they walked their dogs in the Kalorama neighborhood of Washington. (Why is there never a reality show about smart people?)

Likability does matter, and, you know what, it should. It’s not a bad test, in the end. It goes to humanity, temperament and character. And all of those things matter a hell of a lot more than the “issues,” the platform, or the promise of “change” in 2020.

Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).