This is the week of Biden and Buttigieg.
It is Joe Biden’s week because he has finally declared for president, after much Hamlet-like, or feigned Hamlet-like, contemplation of the race. He is 76 and has been in politics almost all of his adult life (the U.S. Senate much of it). He has twice run for president and failed spectacularly. He served honorably and usefully as vice president under Barack Obama.
Mr. Biden’s indecision about running in 2016, partly because he was in a state of deep grief over the death of his son and partly because the Democratic establishment had united behind Hillary Clinton, resulted in the non-run that actually could have worked out. It is very possible that, had he been nominated in 2016, he would be finishing his first term now. Unlike Hillary Clinton, Joe Biden is likable. And, unlike her, he might have held the union vote in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin.
Such are the ironies of politics and life.
But it is hard to shake the feeling that his moment has passed and that Mr. Biden is an almost impossible fit for this moment — 2020. He is like an actor who walks on stage for the wrong play. And he keeps apologizing.
That never helps any suitor.
Read More
He is also hobbled by something that, in a rational politics, would actually help him — long experience and knowledge of the federal system. Americans like something, and somebody, new. And in a presidential race, being new and having much of the press fascinated by you is the greatest advantage imaginable.
Being the front-runner early is never a safe place to be. Ask Jeb Bush.
And that brings us to Pete Buttigieg. He is new. And the press can’t take its eyes off of him. There are good reasons, too.
Mayor Pete has three things going for him. First, he has a brain. He thinks. He even thinks about rock music, the New Testament and war. He is, for a politician, uncommonly thoughtful. This would be obvious even if he did not play the piano and speak Norwegian. Just listen to him.
Second, he conveys intellect without intellectualism. He comes off more like a soulful Methodist pastor than an Al Gore or Adlai Stevenson.
And third, he seems to be sincerely idealistic. He went from Harvard, Oxford and McKinsey & Company to the National Guard and service in Afghanistan. (Eight years in the guard and seven months in the war.) Why? He says he simply thought people of his level of privilege should share the burden with the young men and women from the working poor (sons and daughters of deplorables) who normally make up the volunteer Army.
Back in the day, he says, a guy like John F. Kennedy or George Herbert Walker Bush was expected to serve. And that is a good standard.
True enough. But it says something profound about Mr. Buttigieg that he volunteered and that this was his rationale: Of whom much has been given much should be required.
A cynic might say, “Well he knew he was going to be a politician and that war service would be helpful.” But, think about it: Military service has not mattered, or mattered much, especially in the Democratic Party, for a long time now. It will not help Mr. Buttigieg appreciably in the Democratic presidential primaries. And the mayor of South Bend is nothing if not a rational actor. You do not risk your life in the hellish, unwinnable muck of Afghanistan for a line on a résumé or the theme for a 30-second commercial.
No, I believe the guy. He just might be a true servant leader. And at a moment when the nation feels weary and beat up, he is new. His appeal reminds me very much of Jimmy Carter in 1975 and Bill Clinton in 1991 and early 1992. Mr. Carter, in particular, was seen as an upbeat, independent and thoughtful. And, like those two men, Mayor Pete is also a centrist and pragmatist, not a leftist ideologue.
Of course Bill Clinton had fatal flaws and Jimmy Carter was not prepared for the presidency. Arguably, neither was Barack Obama or JFK — two others with incredible elan and self- possession at young ages.

Being mayor of a small city, or running a failed race for state treasurer or national party chairman, does not qualify a person to be president. Joe Biden is qualified. Few people know more about foreign policy, the judiciary and the justice system, or Congress than Mr. Biden.
He has also often been wrong. Maybe that’s a good thing. Maybe his mistakes are behind him. Maybe he has learned. But, mostly, he seems worn.
What a shame that the old and new cannot be combined. Alas, they cannot be. Youth must err with passion and flail and age must rage against the light it knows is dying.
Mr. Biden has a secret weapon. His heart. He has suffered. And this makes his compassion, in a party of fake compassion, real.
The boy mayor has a secret weapon, too. He can talk. He has a Reagan-like talent for direct, witty and unvarnished communication, as when he said he recognized bait when he saw it and would not take it. He’s connecting right now. And he’s threatening the assumed narrative. “Rivals are scrambling to dig up dirt on Pete Buttigieg,” ran one recent headline.
The New York Times published a story with this headline: “How Pete Buttigieg’s Meaningless Erudition Made Him the ‘Smart’ Candidate.”
Can erudition be meaningless?
Never mind. If I am Mayor Pete, running as champion of the heartland, the outsider who is the anti-Trump, I want The New York Times against me.
Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.