F. Scott Fitzgerald famously said, “There are no second acts in American lives.” But my young, wise friend Sam says something a bit different. He told me a few months back: “There are no second chances in our culture today.” No repentance. No forgiveness. No chance to start again.
He was talking about celebrities, partly. But this truth seems to apply generally. Except for the Kennedy family and Donald Trump, and maybe a few others who can power through scandal, real or contrived, American society has become the land of one mistake.
That’s all you get. Game over.
We have just concluded the Christian season of repentance, culminating in today’s celebration of resurrection, hope and rebirth. And we are in the midst of Passover — the feast of liberation. I wonder if the unforgiving society, the #MeToo society, the gotcha society, the judgment without good or evil society (where hair smelling is verboten but partial-birth abortion is OK) is obliterating second chances.
Some of us are late bloomers, after all. It takes a while for us to process, to get it.
Some of us are slow learners. Where does no second chances leave us?
Read More
There is something to be said for slow learners. They take less for granted. They know gratitude. Wynton Marsalis said of Duke Ellington’s compositions that each note was lovingly and meticulously etched. It didn’t all just flow through him effortlessly, like Mozart, whose notations where quickly and messily scrawled.
For Ellington, the life of the composer came hard. He had to chase the music, which he called an elusive mistress, and fight the bigots and snobs. (He was voted a special Pulitzer citation in 1965, which the Pulitzer board chose not to award — a deeply shameful moment in American cultural life.)
When I was a little boy, age 6 I think, I was in an accident the summer when I was supposed to learn how to swim. My friends learned that summer. I waited for the next summer. Because I was “behind,” my parents were anxious that I learn fast. So they hired my cousin Mary Joe to teach me. (Mary Joe became a feminist theologian in later life. )
Mary Joe was a great swimmer — a natural. But she was so natural that she did not know how to teach. She had no patience. She lacked empathy.
She also saw the act of swimming as one, unified thing. She could not break it down: You dive or jump in. Then you swim.
Cousin Mary Joe and I did not connect.
But at our pool was a man named Paul Samuell. He was head summer lifeguard, or “pool director.” I remember him as about 60, he was probably 40. He smoked a pipe, had a deep tan from days upon days in the sun and taught at the high school in winter months. (I later knew him as adviser to the school newspaper.) Mr. Samuell was the soul of unflappability. Nothing ruffled him. He kept discipline at the poor with calmness.
And Mr. Samuell knew two great truths about teaching: How to be patient and how to break down a challenge — in this case strokes — into separate, small, manageable challenges.
I don’t think I ever actually saw Mr. Samuell swim. So I don’t know if he was a natural swimmer or not. But I know he was a natural teacher and he made me a good swimmer. He was smart and he was analytic and he was, in a word, forgiving.
And because swimming came hard and late to me, it meant more than it did to my mates and peers. And I hung on to it.
These days I have a yoga teacher, a young man young enough to be my grandson, who reminds me of Mr. Samuell. He breaks each posture down and, instead of cajoling, coaxes. He is, in a word, forgiving.
I think, too, of my father teaching me and my sisters to ride a bike. We each got a different teacher. For he understood intuitively that human beings are all wired differently and learn in different ways and at different speeds. And, it’s interesting, the one who used training wheels the longest became the most ardent cyclist.
In a tolerant and civilized society, there is more than one way to learn; there are second chances; and there is time and space for forgiveness.
We know this in our bones. We know it as human beings and as Americans. That’s why we love comebacks. Even if Tiger Woods is not your cup of tea, you have to love his comeback.
I had a famous friend once. When The New York Times informed him that his obit was written and filed and waiting upon his departure from this world, he was both outraged and amused. “How do they know,” he asked me in his 80s, “that I won’t do something really fine on my last day on earth?”
As is written in “Redemption Song,” “We’ve got to fulfill the book.”
So, for all the slow learners and late bloomers comes an Easter message: Second chances are part of the deal.
Or, as a Jewish friend put it to me once: If nothing is forgotten and every experience is used, you have the right to keep trying.
“Emancipate yourselves from mental slavery/None but ourselves can free our minds.”
We need to cut each other some slack in our society and our polity today.
Together, we must sing redemption songs.
Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.