Some years ago, as a relatively new editorial page editor, I learned a lesson in empathy from my then boss and publisher in Connecticut — a wonderful woman named Elizabeth Ellis.
The situation was that a man in one of the towns our newspaper covered had effectively committed suicide by cop. Hepped up on booze and pills, he charged, at some distance, at two rookie cops who had come to his home for a domestic dispute. He had something in his hand, which turned out not to be a gun. They shot him. He died. A suspension and investigation ensued. The cops were cleared.
I wanted to throw the editorial book at the young cops. It seemed to me this was excessive force for the perceived threat. Experienced cops would have likely found another way. (I still think that.)
My publisher, a fervent liberal Democrat, asked me a simple question: Ever been a cop?
She said it is easy to second guess a young, relatively inexperienced person in a life-and-death situation with seconds to make a decision that could end his days, or another’s, forever.
I have since gotten to know a few police officers, and it would be impossible to overstate, as a former mayor I know put it, the uncertainty and fear policemen and policewomen face every day.
Read More
One young cop I know is very happy to have just made detective. He says that, though the people he deals with are not exactly nature’s finest, he more or less knows what sort of situation he is walking into most of the time.
Not so on the streets. The street cop never knows what is coming next or who is coming at him. Every traffic stop, every knock on the door for a domestic, is a roll of the dice, and contains a certain amount of built-in terror.
And this element of uncertainly has only increased over the last 20 years.
I don’t think most of us have much of a clue about the daily lives of police officers.
And police officers are loath to tell their stories, except in private.
Fast forward a few years.
I was interviewing a gentleman who was a Vietnam veteran, an ex-CIA agent, and a sitting U.S congressman, and we had just learned that a prominent politician had been involved, when a military officer, in a massacre in a village in Vietnam. I thought my soldier-spook-congressman pal would say: Listen, man, unless you have walked in those shoes you cannot judge. You don’t know what it was like over there.
He didn’t. Instead he shook his head and said: No. No. You cannot do that. You just cannot. There are rules, even in war.
I think of all this when I think of the Micheal Rosfeld trial in Pittsburgh.
Not only Pittsburghers but many across the nation followed the trial of former police officer Rosfeld in the shooting death of 17-year-old Antwon Rose II. Mr. Rosfeld was acquitted of all charges.
The young cop stopped a car that had been in a drive-by shooting. He cornered its inhabitants, cuffed one, and two ran. He shot to stop them. Antwon died. He was unarmed.
But someone in that car had had a gun. The jury concluded that Mr. Rosfeld had reason to fear for his life and the life of the community.
I spoke with a friend who is a veteran police officer and public safety administrator. He said the jury’s verdict did not surprise him a bit. It was the officer’s perception that his life and the lives of others were at risk. That was determinative.
And yet this broadly and deeply experienced policeman also said that, if we are to prevent these tragic incidents in the future, there have to be rules of engagement, even in a kind of war.
The most important tool a police officer has in such an incident, he said, is his radio. Deal with the man you have in custody. You’ve got him and the car. Let your brothers in blue, your backup, know your situation. They will find the other guys.
I spoke with another police vet who made the same point in a different way: In training young officers, he said, we emphasize one idea — slow everything down. Time is on your side.
Young officers, he told me, go from zero to 90 in 30 seconds. Veterans slow things down to achieve a measure of control, which may save a life, or two. Maybe their own. It’s hard to craft a proportional, or minimal response, in a decisional or shooting moment. Time can buy you proportion.
In some cities, including Toledo, new cops take two weeks of scenario training after the academy. This is invaluable real-world simulation — acting out such events as an old lady backing an officer into a corner with a meat cleaver or an angry husband with an ax.
One of my police rabbis is also a huge advocate of yearly re-training for cops. He says a community that cannot afford this cannot afford to have a police force at all.
What else helps? Body cams, he said. And Tasers. They allow a response that is effective but non-lethal.
But, most of all, careful recruiting and training in best practices: When to shoot and when not to shoot. How to dial it down. How to follow without siren and lights until backup comes. How to deal with one suspect and one scenario at a time. How to not go from zero to 90 in seconds and to use time to your advantage. If you can get the bad guys in good time, with help, you need not be a superhero. And you may not need to shoot.
Empathy. We cannot have enough of it for troubled kids or frightened cops. But many people might be surprised at the empathy experienced cops feel on a too frequent basis these days. No one is more bothered than they are when an arrest goes south, shots are fired, and a young boy dies.
Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.