The inability of many Americans, including not a few Democratic politicians in the U.S. House, to resist the lure of impeachment is a kind of political madness.

The argument is not legal and it is almost certainly bad politics for the Dems. It is emotional. It is based on an almost blind hatred for President Donald Trump.

That emotion will eventually pass. The more pernicious and possibly lasting legacy is a profound one — the refusal of large swaths of the country to accept the results of elections.

This is, in democratic theory, sometimes called the concept or doctrine of legitimacy.

Advertise with us

The doctrine might be summarized this way: We try to run free and fair elections in this country and the people, the press, the elites and the ancillary political institutions are expected to accept the results. It’s a compact.

It has kept our politics stable.

Even though he knew there was a good chance John F. Kennedy stole the election in 1960, Richard Nixon chose not to challenge the outcome.

Even though the Supreme Court unnecessarily and unconstitutionally short-circuited the 2000 election, Al Gore accepted the result.

Neither Nixon, nor Mr. Gore, nor their parties, spent the next four years calling President Kennedy or President George W. Bush a pretender, or an illegitimate president.

Advertise with us

A few people did. But an entire opposition party, aided by powerful elites, did not seek to remove either man from office by investigation and then impeachment.

The plan for Mr. Trump was that the special counsel would find evidence of high crimes and this would queue up impeachment.

But after more than two years of extensive and bottomless investigation, of a kind that few politicians could withstand, there is no such evidence.

Robert Mueller’s report cleared the president himself of collusion with the Russian government — a charge many Americans found far-fetched from the start. (It found ample evidence of Russian dirty tricks, however.)

And, despite clumsy threats by the president against the Mueller probe, Mr. Mueller and his team got every interview, witness and piece of paper they requested from the White House.

Advertise with us

In the end, the whole conspiracy fantasy and alleged cover-up amounted to a nullity. And Mr. Mueller, a seemingly straight arrow, made two bizarre assertions when he held a press conference last week. First, that a president cannot be charged with a crime by the Department of Justice. And, second, that while he could not say the president committed a crime, neither could he say he did not.

That is, Mr Mueller could not charge the president, even if he had the evidence to do so. (So what was all this about and why did Mr. Mueller take the job?) But neither could he assure the nation of the president’s complete innocence.

Hence the new standard of American justice became, for a flickering moment, certainty of innocence.

In our system, the standard is certainty of guilt.

And if a prosecutor feels he cannot prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, his most eloquent course is silence. He should, as prosecutors usually do, let his inaction speak for him.

Advertise with us

In our system, that silence is exoneration.

The practical problem for Democrats now is going to be explaining to the country just what high crimes they think have been committed.

Demeaning one’s opponents, one’s office, or one’s self is not a crime, high or low. Acting unpresidential is not a crime. Failing to understand the presidency is not a crime.

They are serious matters — of character, of comprehension, and of leadership. But they are political issues not legal ones.

Democrats have a political case. That is the case that should be made.

Advertise with us

But the Trump haters cannot see this. (Nancy Pelosi, I think, does.)

Impeachment is not only a distraction from the presidential election now upon us, but it makes the Democrats dependent on the coups of elites rather than the will of the people.

And that is no accident.

Many a Democrat will tell you: We can’t trust another election. What if the people re-elect Mr. Trump? That’s why we have to impeach him.

What will happen, do you think, when a future, GOP House thinks a Democrat is unworthy and illegitimate?

Advertise with us

What if they seek impeachment because “that guy can’t be president”?

Then we no longer have our system.

We almost do not now.

Neither right nor left can grasp that core democratic precepts, like legitimacy, and due process of law, matter more than any man and the ire he stirs within us.

Impeachment would only continue our descent into utter political soap opera and farce. And it would tear at the fabric of the republic. For it would be based on no constitutional issues but on one thing only: The people made a mistake electing you.

Advertise with us

I say, take it back to the people, Democrats. Trust the people. Over the long run, they have done pretty well. Trust in the next election, not impeachment. Make your case directly. Make your case on decency and substance. Trust the results of our imperfect but noble electoral system. And accept them.

Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).