Nine years ago, on a Public Television Station in Detroit, I participated in a panel discussion on the surging epidemic of addiction to heroin, prescription painkillers and other opioids. Members of the panel talked about county jails as revolving doors for people with addictions, and why jails and prisons are ground-zero in the fight against addiction.

To make my point, I asked the panel to imagine a story that could have come from Mr. Rogers’ neighborhood, or any neighborhood in the country:

Let’s say police arrest 24-year-old John Jones for stealing two pairs of Beats headphones at Walmart. Mr. Jones, who shot some heroin two hours before, plans to boost the headphones for drug money.

After his arrest, however, Jones goes straight to a jail holding cell. He’s still high and feels a waning euphoria. But facing two weeks in the county jail, he knows the agony of withdrawal nears. With heroin, he has touched the hand of God, but it’s about to take him into the depths of hell.

Advertise with us

In a few hours, Jones starts feigning. He is coming down, feeling increasingly edgy; his skin starts to prick. Over the next few days, he is gripped by bone-crunching body aches, cold sweats, fever, nausea and diarrhea. He twists and writhes on a vomit-smeared concrete floor, as a crushing depression settles in.

The jail has nothing to ease his pain. He cannot get methadone or Suboxone, prescription drugs for recovering addicts in treatment. He feels like he’ll die, but he survives.

Two weeks later, Jones is back on the street, fighting an irresistible urge. He steals $50 from his mother and buys three stamp bags of heroin to get well. In another month, he’s back in jail, or dead, after unknowingly ingesting a lethal shot of fentanyl.

“Why would anyone, after going through all that, go out and do it again?” the moderator asked me.

Losing logic 

Advertise with us

It was a perfectly rational and logical question, posed by someone whose mind had never been hijacked by the disease of addiction, where everyday rules don’t apply. In talking about how to treat it, you need to throw out logic and lose conventional ways of thinking.

Allegheny County, along with counties throughout Pennsylvania and the nation, is starting to decide how to spend billions of dollars to fight addiction. They will receive the money, starting now, over the next decade or two from a flurry of state and local lawsuits against pharmaceutical manufacturers, distributors and others who helped jumpstart the U.S. opioid epidemic in the 1990s. More than $2 billion will come directly to Pennsylvania. Allegheny County will get at least $82 million through December of 2038.

Using a public health model, counties should spend the money on proven solutions to treat addiction and reduce harm — in other words, to keep addicts alive long enough to recover — even if those ideas seem crazy and irrational to many people. Evidence and science should guide them, not fear, biases or ignorance.

Treating the disease

Take supervised injection sites, which a non-profit wants to open in Philadelphia, as a case-in-point. Over the past year, these highly controversial sites have prevented nearly 700 overdoses in New York, and saved many lives around the world.

Advertise with us

No doubt, giving heroin users a legal area, supervised by public health professionals, to inject heroin sounds crazy as hell. By conventional logic and reason, it’s tantamount to encouraging or condoning illegal and destructive drug use.

But that’s not at all what it’s doing. At these sites, counselors, many of them recovering addicts, work to get users into treatment quickly. Meantime, however, they keep users alive by acknowledging that addicts will continue to use, regardless of the consequences. I’ve heard stories on the street that increased fatalities actually encourage some users to use a particular cocktail because they believe it will really pack a wallop. Now, that is crazy.

There are plenty of progressive models that have proven effective that Allegheny County ought to consider. Some of them are controversial and outside-the-box, such as mobile methadone programs, managed by medical workers, with same-day signs ups; needle exchanges; and, yes, supervised injection sites. Gov.-elect Josh Shapiro opposes them, but he’s never been addicted.

Addiction is not a moral failure; it’s an all-consuming disease. With more than 20 million Americans infected, more than 5,000 people a year in Pennsylvania, and 100,000 nationwide, die of drug overdoes. Addiction has ruined the lives of untold millions more, and disrupted the lives of countless families and friends.

Many people caught up in addiction have extraordinary talents and gifts to contribute. As Allegheny County decides which anti-addiction programs to fund, those of us who live here must make sure public officials do whatever is necessary to pull them out of of this nightmare — even if some people call us crazy.

Pulitzer Prize winner Jeffery Gerritt is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.