I am an Iranian American Jew, and I support the preemptive actions taken against the Iranian regime. It is a subject of discussion everywhere, of course, and I know something about the discussion in Pittsburgh, including in this newspaper through Rabbi Seth Adelson, who led my congregation when he was in Long Island and has written for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

I support the actions not because I am indifferent to human suffering, but because I take it seriously enough to ask a harder question: What happens if this regime is allowed to continue on its current path?

Like many, I am deeply troubled by the loss of civilian life. War is tragic. Every innocent life lost is a tragedy. But focusing only on the consequences of this moment, while ignoring the decades-long reality that led to it, presents a dangerously incomplete picture.

The regime

Reasonable people can disagree on this issue. But disagreement requires a full accounting of the facts, and that begins with understanding the nature of the regime in question.

Advertise with us

Some critics of the American and Israeli action will admit that Iran is controlled by a theocratic dictatorship. That should not be a passing remark or concession before rejecting the action as it often is. It should be the starting point.

For over four decades, the Iranian regime has funded and armed groups like Hezbollah, Hamas and the Houthis, fueling instability across the Middle East. It has been linked to the deaths of Americans, Israelis and countless civilians. At home, it has ruled through repression, imprisoning, torturing and killing its own people.

This is not incidental behavior. It is a consistent pattern.

Yet many of the critics ask us to mourn the consequences of war while largely ignoring the consequences of allowing this behavior to continue unchecked.

They also usually fail to make a clear distinction between the Iranian regime and the Iranian people. For decades, the Iranian population has lived under a system that suppresses dissent, crushes protest movements and denies basic freedoms. Millions of Iranians have risked — and lost — their lives demanding change. Entire movements have been silenced through force, surveillance and fear.

Advertise with us

To describe Iran as a unified actor is to ignore a fundamental reality: The Iranian people are not the regime. They are held hostage by it.

The regime’s nuclear ambitions, regional aggression and ideological rigidity are not expressions of the will of its people. They are imposed upon them.

Which raises a necessary question: If the concern is truly for the Iranian people, why is there so little focus on the system that has oppressed them for decades and so much focus on those confronting it?

The omission

The most serious omission in many critics’ argument, however, is the nuclear issue. Iran has enriched uranium to levels far beyond what is necessary for civilian use— dangerously close to weapons-grade.

There is no credible peaceful justification for enrichment at this level. Combined with Iran’s long history of concealment and its openly hostile ideology, this raises a critical question:

Advertise with us

What happens if this regime acquires nuclear weapons? History offers a clear warning. Once regimes like North Korea obtained nuclear capability, they did not become more restrained. They become more emboldened and harder to confront.

Are we prepared to see that dynamic play out with Iran?

As a Jew, I also cannot ignore the regime’s repeated calls for the destruction of Israel — calls that are not merely rhetorical but backed by funding, weapons and long-term strategy.

Many critics of the war frame it as an way to gain control of Iran’s oil and dismiss concerns about security as pretext. But this oversimplifies a far more dangerous reality. Geopolitics is always complex, and the United States is not without fault in its history. But complexity does not erase the existence of real threats.

Multiple things can be true at once: Governments may act with mixed motives, and a regime can still pose a genuine and growing danger.

Advertise with us

We should also be honest about the limits of past approaches. Years of diplomacy, sanctions and negotiations have failed to fundamentally alter the regime’s trajectory. Its regional influence has expanded, not contracted. Its nuclear capabilities have advanced, not diminished.

What is most striking, however, is what so much criticism leaves out.

Where are the voices of the Iranian people who have risked their lives to oppose this regime? Where is the focus on those who have been imprisoned, beaten, and killed for demanding basic freedoms?

Why is there no sustained advocacy for the tens of millions of Iranians who want freedom from a government that has ruled through fear for nearly half a century?

The Iranian people are not the regime. But ignoring the regime does not protect them. It condemns them to it.

Advertise with us

The question

War is tragic. That is undeniable.

But so is allowing a regime that exports violence, represses its citizens and stands on the threshold of nuclear capability to operate without consequence.

The choice is not between war and peace in the abstract. It is between confronting a dangerous reality now or facing a far more dangerous one later.

So the question remains: If not this — then what?

Bobby Bakhchi is an attorney and entrepreneur in New York City. The views expressed are his own.