I grew up in Washington, Pa., about 30 miles south of Pittsburgh, in a county that voted for Trump twice by double digits. The people I talk to back home were, until recently, content to rail about illegal immigration in the abstract.

The situation in Charleroi, a small Washington County borough where several hundred Haitian workers arrived to staff a food processing plant, straining schools and the police budget, was a local grievance with real teeth. Trump name-checked the town during the 2024 campaign.

But recently the conversation has shifted significantly.

Distant authorities

The people who were angry about Charleroi are now talking about ICE the way their grandparents talked about the federal government during Prohibition and the way earlier ancestors talked about the whiskey tax in 1794. Our regional memory is long: overreach by distant authorities does not go over well.

Advertise with us

A mid-February statewide survey from RealClear Opinion Research and Emerson Polling backs up what I know about my hometown. It found 58% of Pennsylvania residents think ICE enforcement has gone too far. Only 17% think it hasn’t gone far enough.

The Keystone State numbers only get worse for ICE from there. Eighty-six percent support requiring agents to wear body cameras and 53% want agents prohibited from wearing masks during operations. Solid majorities support allowing residents to sue if ICE violates constitutional rights (66%) and want ICE barred from arrests on state property (58%). A plurality (45%) still oppose eliminating ICE outright, but that’s not a majority, and the desire to eliminate the agency spans party lines.

Fifty-five percent of Pennsylvanians are concerned about immigration-related arrests in their area, with Hispanic residents at 64% and white residents at 52%. Almost half believe Congress should reform ICE even if it means a temporary government shutdown. Pennsylvanians are split on local police cooperation with federal immigration authorities: 37% say always cooperate, 37% say only sometimes, 16% say never.

Class anger

There’s a class dimension to this anger, too. My stepdad is a retired union coal miner from Indiana County who spent 35 years underground, much of it on his knees. He is anything but soft on immigration. However, as he watches the seemingly endless flood of TV coverage of ICE raids, he returns to the same point: “Trump’s not going after his rich buddies.”

He means the meatpacking companies, the big agricultural operations, the construction outfits that have relied on undocumented labor for decades because it’s cheap and disposable. A competent enforcement campaign would have targeted those employers first, using E-Verify mandates and employer sanctions to dry up the jobs that draw unauthorized workers.

Advertise with us

Instead, ICE has produced a series of individual arrests, physical confrontations caught on camera and fatal shootings. People in Washington County know what it looks like when the government comes down hard on the little guy while the bosses skate.

The survey suggests my stepfather isn’t alone in thinking the enforcement priorities are backwards E-Verify — the federal government’s program that allows enrolled employers to confirm the eligibility of their employees to work in the United States — polls reasonably well at 53% approval (only 12% think it is a bad thing), with strongest support in finance and real estate (71%) and construction (67%).

Pennsylvanians, in other words, are open to cracking down on the businesses that hire undocumented workers. They’re far less interested in watching masked federal agents shoot angry soccer moms or nab grandmothers and elementary school kids in parking lots. Forty-two percent thought DHS Secretary Kristi Noem should resign, against 29% who said she should stay.

However, on the issue of whether immigrants have been good for their communities, although almost half say positive, almost a third say negative. The partisan gap here is enormous: 72% of Democrats say positive, while 41% of Republicans say negative. Indeed, anyone who has spent time in a place like Charleroi knows this is a far from settled issue and heavily affected by how many immigrants are actually in the area where the polled individuals live.

The political fallout is also landing unevenly. Gov. Josh Shapiro holds a 47 to 23% approval-disapproval split, a comfortable position as his reelection approaches (although his refusal to take a clear stance on the relatively popular Save Women’s Sports Act has frustrated both sides).

Advertise with us

Sen. David McCormick sits at 30 to 29%, with his alignment to the Trump administration’s immigration posture leaving him no daylight from ICE’s unpopularity. Sen. John Fetterman fares slightly better at 38 to 32% — though his latter-day “straight talk express” bipartisan positioning isn’t insulating him from the broader discontent.

The parking chair rule

The Pittsburgh parking chair captures this region’s self-policing ability. The practice is technically illegal, but Pittsburgh police have looked the other way for more than a century. Even the mayor asked Pittsburghers after the big snowstorm, “Please respect the chair law in the neighborhoods.”

It has no legal standing. It relies on mutual respect between neighbors and a shared understanding that you control what you dug out. It’s a custom that solves with rough fairness one problem of urban living. And it works.

ICE agents showing up in masks, without body cameras, arresting people on state property? That’s someone moving your chair. It doesn’t matter whether you liked the person they grabbed.

The principle is the same: You don’t come into my neighborhood and impose your rules without my say-so, especially if you’re not giving the big bosses at the top the same rough treatment.

Oliver Bateman, a contributing writer for the Post-Gazette editorial page who writes every other Thursday, is a historian, widely published journalist and author of the Substack “Oliver Bateman Does the Work.” He lives in Pittsburgh.