In his first month, Corey O’Connor’s administration has been strikingly quiet about the intensifying challenges facing Pittsburgh’s immigrant communities. National and local media are focused on the billows of smoke rising from the streets in Minneapolis, along with how the courts are dealing with Trump’s bullish usage of presidential immunity.

Closer to home, Gov. Josh Shapiro has been making the late-night talk show rounds, warning that Philadelphia is likely going to be Minnesota 2.0.

Yet at this moment, neither he, O’Connor, nor anyone else seems to have a clear plan for how to guarantee the basic rights and protections that, just a year ago, most of us assumed were settled and secure for both immigrants and citizens alike.

The fallout

As a former manager of Pittsburgh’s Office of Immigrant & Refugee Affairs, I saw firsthand how the fallout from these changes affected these communities.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh’s immigrant community is not monolithic. It includes international students with families anxiously tracking events in America, naturalized citizens who followed every legal pathway available to them, asylum seekers whose cases are still under review, and people who were fully documented 12 months ago but lost their status due to sudden and arbitrary shifts in federal policy.

This complexity rarely shows up in the way immigration is portrayed in much of our political discourse.

If your social media algorithm looks anything like mine, you’ve probably seen how many people believe that the current crackdown is simply about rounding up dangerous criminals who “rape and pillage” our communities and the treasuries that fund our basic services and social safety nets (evidence to the contrary be damned!). If nonviolent undocumented immigrants, green card holders or even citizens get swept up in these actions, that’s just an unfortunate exception — the necessary price of “making America great again.”

We’ll thank them later.

This logic misses a fundamental point. What makes this country strong isn’t simply law enforcement — It’s the rights and protections that apply to all “persons” here. Due process, civil rights and basic human dignity are not legal technicalities — They are values that have historically united Americans across political lines.

Advertise with us

A recent Pew poll found only 39% of Americans approve of Trump’s approach to immigration — a minority, but still tens of millions of people whose fears cannot be ignored. Those who support his approach tend to see a rapidly changing world and believe America has a moral obligation to preserve its hegemony within it.

On the other side, I hear profound distrust of the political right and a demand for a country — and a world — where birthplace and skin color no longer dictate opportunity.

In both cases, these positions are grounded in deeply held personal moral convictions. Because of this, it is difficult to bridge the divide in our country. But while we fight on Facebook, immigrants are bearing the brunt of our national disagreements.

Immigrant inclusion

For more than a decade, the placement of the Office of Immigrant & Refugee Affairs within the mayor’s office has underscored the city’s commitment to immigrant inclusion and helped shape its approach to these issues. Both the Peduto and Gainey administrations deserve credit for making city services more accessible and welcoming to its foreign-born residents.

Through initiatives like the International Day Parade and World Square, they elevated cultures that had long been overlooked and, in doing so, earned meaningful trust among immigrant communities. O’Connor has said he intends to continue this work. Yet so far, his administration has not clearly articulated what that commitment will look like in practice.

Advertise with us

What Pittsburgh’s immigrant community wants to know is simple: What are their leaders going to do to protect them from this latest wave of hate that is sweeping through America?

More than that, people are looking for moral clarity. We want leaders who can speak plainly, stand up for vulnerable communities, and build a genuine, bipartisan coalition around basic human rights without resorting to the pitfalls of cancel culture and partisan politics.

For the most part, people on every side of this issue share one thing — we want to feel safe. True safety, however, depends on the same principles that have always made this country strong: equal rights, due process and basic human dignity for all. And we honor our own rights most fully when we are willing to honor them for others.

A city and state coalition

The question then is how these principles should shape leadership at the state and local level. Local leaders in cities like Pittsburgh are often caught in the crossfire of America’s culture wars. What is needed is broader coalition-building on this issue at the state level.

When Pittsburgh’s approaches are aligned with clear state-level laws and standards, it gives the mayor stronger footing to be both principled and pragmatic in his local public safety priorities. O’Connor is in a good position to start this conversation with the governor and other welcoming municipalities in the state.

Advertise with us

It’s time for O’Connor and Shapiro to step up. We are tired of polished speeches and slick social media campaigns. What matters now is whether they have the courage and political skill to defend immigrants and unite Pennsylvanians around a shared vision for what a welcoming state should be.

They still have time to figure this out. But the ICE circus is coming to Pennsylvania — and the clock is ticking.

Nathan Harper was the manager of Pittsburgh’s Office of Immigrant & Refugee Affairs under Mayor Ed Gainey.