Margaret Thatcher was a great prime minister, up there with William Gladstone and Winston Churchill, and Thatcherism was a necessary response to pressing problems. But the Conservative Party to which she devoted her life lies in ruins and its American sister, the Republican Party, has been hijacked by an authoritarian populist.
And Thatcher herself bears some responsibility for this. She led the transformation of Anglo-Saxon conservatism into a revolutionary political doctrine that may have destroyed conservatism itself.
Thatcherite radicalism
Thatcher devoted her political career to upending the postwar political consensus, with its emphasis on the cooperation of labor and capital and its ethos of “managed decline.” She crushed her enemies at home (the striking coal miners) and abroad (the Argentinian government that invaded the Falklands) and lent unstinting support to Ronald Reagan’s mission to destroy the Soviet Empire.
This spirit of “there is no alternative” radicalism entered the soul of the Conservative Party. To be sure, some Conservatives tried to forge a more compassionate conservatism but the spirit of Thatcherite radicalism kept reasserting itself.
That spirit could be found in Tory publications such as the Daily Telegraph that sometimes read like the Morning Star (once the Daily Worker) in their enthusiasm for uprooting established institutions. It could be found in Tory politicians such as Michael Gove, who kept a poster of Lenin on his wall when he was secretary of state for education in 2010-14 to show what he wanted to do to the educational establishment (or “blob” as he dubbed it).
And above all it could be found in the debate over Britain’s membership of the European Union — a debate that Thatcher did her best to guide and electrify after she was expelled from office.
Radical Brexiteers
Tory “Brexiteers” were the most revolutionary people ever to wear the Tory Party’s blue rosette. They backed the referendum even though it introduced plebiscitary democracy into a parliamentary system. They demonized anybody who supported compromise as “traitors” and “saboteurs.”
They put a succession of dismal leaders in place in an obsessive desire to deliver the hardest possible Brexit. The lead strategist of the “out” campaign was committed to delivering Brexit “by any means necessary,” a reference to a speech by Malcolm X on violence in the pursuit of justice.
The Conservative Party’s sister party across the Atlantic, the Republicans, followed the same model of revolutionary radicalism punctuated by a few nervous pauses such as Bush senior’s initial denunciation of “voodoo economics” and Bush junior’s flirtation with “compassionate conservatism.”
Ronald Reagan tore up the rules of responsible fiscal management. Newt Gingrich perfected the art of political war while dreaming up futurist fantasies about sending the handicapped to outer space.
After Sept. 11, George W. Bush embraced a combination of unilateral war-making — is ally Richard Perle quipped that the essence of U.S. foreign policy was “who’s next?” with a utopian project to democratize the Middle East. Just as the British Tory establishment eventually surrendered to the Brexiteers, so the American Republican establishment showed the white flag to Trumpian populism.
Revolutionary seduction
Why did this spirit of revolutionary conservatism prove so seductive in the short term and destructive in the longer term? There are two answers.
An obvious answer lies partly in a peculiar combination of success and failure. Both Thatcher and Reagan enjoyed extraordinary success in privatizing industries, deregulating markets and generally unleashing entrepreneurial energies.
That encouraged their successors to imitate their radicalism. But they also failed to arrest the shift of the culture to the left or to get a grip on the independent-minded permanent state. That failure provoked conservatives to a fury at the status quo and to demand further radicalization.
A deeper answer lies in the way that revolutionary conservatism swept aside the guardrails that older conservatives placed on the political order. Older conservatives strongly favored tradition over change.
Edmund Burke’s judgment
Indeed Edmund Burke, conservatism’s greatest philosopher, insisted that the conservative must resist change and only approve it very reluctantly. “It is with infinite caution,” he said, “that any man ought to venture upon pulling down an edifice which has answered in any tolerable degree for ages the common purposes of society.”
He devoted an entire book to rejecting the spirit of revolution. The conservative preference for tradition leads to a reverence for institutions, a culture of compromise and a suspicion of “the people.”
Revolutionary conservatism sweeps all these cautions aside in their enthusiasm for embracing either the market, or the people, or both. Thatcher pronounced that “there is no such thing as society” and subjected society’s intermediate institutions, such as local government and universities, to the ruthless calculus of utilitarianism.
Both the Brexiteers and the Trumpists have embraced Rousseau’s revolutionary idea of the “will of the people” in place of Burke’s abhorrence of the mob. Trump, who unleashed a mob on Jan. 6, 2021, is forever weakening constraints on executive power in the name not just of the technical majority of voters who voted for him in 2024, but of the 100% of “real Americans” who, in his mind, will always support him.
Thatcher’s devoured children
The French journalist Jacques Mallet Du Pan observed back in 1793, when Lady Guillotine ran red with blood, that revolutions have a habit of devouring their own children. This has certainly happened with the parties that embraced Thatcher’s revolutionary conservatism.
The British Conservative Party is in the process of being sidelined by the populist party Reform and the GOP is in the hands of an authoritarian strong man.
The only way to prevent this cannibal feast from getting any bloodier is to revive the basic principles of traditional conservatism: principles that emphasize caution and moderation rather than revolutionary zeal.
Adrian Wooldridge is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. His previous article was “A century of civil wars helps explain modern populism.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.