In June of 1851, Charles Wedley was kidnapped in Pittsburgh, marched to Maryland, and nearly sold to a slave master. He was a nineteen year old Black man who lived in the city’s Seventh Ward with his grandmother and four younger siblings.
Wedley’s troubles began when two visitors heard of his plans to travel to Philadelphia. They offered to bring him east. This was a set-up, however, for when they arrived at Licking Creek in Bedford County, “a gang of ruffians rushed upon Wedley, and declared that they knew him well — that he was a slave, and had escaped from Wheeling.”
Wedley was then taken into Maryland and offered for sale to a slave owner. However, this enslaver quickly realized that he “knew too much, and would not only run off himself, but cause his other slaves to escape.” He refused to purchase Wedley and allowed him to return to Pittsburgh.
Wedley’s story was then reported by the Pittsburgh Gazette and spread across the North, reprinted in at least fourteen different newspapers. Several framed Wedley’s ordeal as the fruit of the Fugitive Slave Law passed by Congress the previous year. They argued, as one newspaper put it, that the “Kidnapping has received quite an impulse from the Fugitive Law, especially in Pennsylvania.”
A bad compromise
As part of the Congressional legislation called the Compromise of 1850 — a compromise between free and slave states — Southern enslavers were given a strengthened Fugitive Slave Law. This law came in response to an increasing number of northern “personal liberty laws” that barred local courts and police from collaborating with Southern enslavers.
In 1826, Pennsylvania had been among the first northern states to pass such a law. These laws enraged southerners much as similar “Sanctuary City” laws in Pittsburgh and elsewhere have come under fire from the Trump administration. The Fugitive Slave Law of 1850 gave federal commissioners and marshals new power to circumvent local courts, juries, and law enforcement.
The law barred alleged fugitives from testifying and provided for only summary hearings. As one congressman argued in 1851, it “exposes all colored persons to be seized and sent into bondage for life, ‘without due process of law,’ and in violation of … the Constitution.”
Given these threats, thousands fled following the passage of the Fugitive Slave Law. According to an observer from Pittsburgh, “nearly all the waiters in the hotels have fled to Canada,” and perhaps 800 Black Pittsburghers fled in the final months of 1850.
Those that remained in the city were among the boldest. According to one local report: “The escaped slaves have all armed themselves and declare that they were resolved to die rather than be again carried into bondage.”
After the passage of the Fugitive Slave Law, vigilance committees led by local African Americans in Pittsburgh and other cities resolved to confront Federal Marshalls, sometimes with force. Among the most famous rescues, in February 1851, fugitive Shadrach Minkins in Boston was liberated when “the door of the court [was] pressed open by a crowd of sympathizing colored persons,” who “seize[d] their doomed brother” and placed him “beyond the reach of his pursuers.”
Just as masked ICE agents in unmarked cars have recently been reported to police as kidnappers, antislavery advocates in the 1850s confronted Federal Marshals as corrupt kidnappers. In Chautauqua, New York, authorities attempting to recapture a slave “were followed by some half-dozen men with rifles, shouting ‘Man-Stealers, ‘Kidnappers’.”
Slavery and immigration
With escalating ICE raids across the country and with Trump’s “Big Beautiful Bill” providing billions for ICE, another vulnerable group of workers and neighbors feels a similar threat of capture and removal.
In late June, fourteen undocumented residents were arrested in Allegheny County, and the next day, protesters marched on the ICE headquarters in Pittsburgh. According to Public Source, since Trump took office, ICE has arrested at least 447 people in the Pittsburgh region (the area within a 50-mile radius of Downtown).
As the Post-Gazette recently reported, the number of immigrants held in detention for deportation in Western Pennsylvania has doubled compared to the same period last year. Pittsburgh is, so far, not one of ICE’s major targets, but it could become one.
Even those who think their place in the United States is secure, as Charles Wedley surely did in 1851, have been swept up in this recent wave of mass raids. Alarming numbers of United States citizens of Latinx background have been detained by ICE.
As a historian who studies labor, slavery and anti-immigrant politics in the nineteenth century, with a particular focus on the history of Pittsburgh, I see close parallels between the recent confrontations over immigration and the struggle over the Fugitive Slave Law in the 1850s. A large undocumented workforce without full civil and political rights is a problem in a free and democratic society.
This was also the problem of slavery. Slavery was an intentionally sustained labor system that created an exploitable, vulnerable population. So is unauthorized migration. Many sectors rely on this cheap, unprotected labor, and aggressive enforcement makes the undocumented more vulnerable and exploitable. Living in fear, undocumented workers are unable to protest common problems such as wage theft and dangerous working conditions.
When the cost to American businesses of enforcing the law becomes too great and too politically costly, it will stop.To calm business interests, Trump has already suggested expanding “guest worker” programs that bind immigrants to a specific employer with minimal rights. This would truly resurrect a system of unfree labor.
Mass deportation is unfeasible. It is also inhumane and unnecessary. The raids and arrests serve primarily as authoritarian theater meant to embolden nativists and terrorize immigrants. The history of the Fugitive Slave Law, as a brutal attempt to sustain an inhumane system, suggests that America’s future as a free and democratic society requires a path to full civil, labor, and political rights for every person who lives and works in the United States.
Rudi Batzell is an associate professor of history at Lake Forest College and author of “Organizing Workers in the Shadow of Slavery.” Pittsburgh was one of the four case studies used in the book.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.