I loved Pope Francis. He accepted the difficult job of bishop of Rome. He didn’t make it look easy.
St. John Paul II spent his heroic youth opposing Nazis and Stalinists. His extravagant magnanimity suited the new age of mass media. Benedict XVI wrote and gave live interviews in a deceptively relaxed manner that concealed his unsurpassed intelligence.
Following these heroes, poor Pope Francis cut an awkward public figure. He used clumsy words at clumsy times — like a grumpy Italian grandpa, as one of my colleagues put it. Francis was often impatient with those of us slow to follow his lead. He scorned the aristocratic polish of the Roman curia, the Catholic Church’s bureaucracy.
But by his service, Francis showed that being Catholic is more than moral heroism and exacting doctrinal precision. Catholicity is also family, formed by the special favor of Jesus, who adopts us as his little brothers and sisters.
We are family
Francis’ encyclical, Fratelli tutti, “On Fraternity and Social Friendship,” didn’t get much attention in the U.S. It didn’t touch the biggest controversies of American politics. But it was the great project of Francis’ pontificate that we should try to be “the brother [or sister] of all.” I loved Francis for how he made himself a witness to the shared life of Christian family, and the hope of universal fraternity, however imperfectly. From Francis I take hope for my own priestly ministry.
But I loved Pope Francis also for his other writings. They challenged me more than John Paul’s clear moral exhortations and Benedict’s indisputably correct doctrine. Francis didn’t just reinforce what I already believed. Francis taught me things I wouldn’t have learned without him. As G.K. Chesterton is often quoted, “We do not want a religion that is right where we are right. What we want is a religion that is right where we are wrong.”
Read More
One example was Francis’ 2013 letter, Evangelii Gaudium, “The Joy of the Gospel.” Francis criticized us clergymen like none other in many centuries. He wrote, “I want to remind the priests that the confessional is not a torture chamber, but rather an encounter with the Lord’s mercy.” Ouch! Or, “They [the people] and their ordained ministers suffer because of homilies: the laity from having to listen to them and the clergy from having to preach them.” Double ouch! But for Francis’ sake, I redoubled my efforts to preach homilies that can be received as good news by the faithful.
Another example was the Pope’s 2015 encyclical, Laudato si’, “On Care for our Common Home.” Francis called for a global conversation on major environmental issues: “The earth, our home, is beginning to look more and more like an immense pile of filth.” Again, ouch! But even as Francis evoked the enthusiasm of environmentalists, he smuggled in John Paul’s teaching on sexuality: “Learning to accept our body, to care for it and respect its fullest meaning, is an essential element of human ecology.” Francis confounded conservatives and liberals alike, much as Jesus confounded many with his parables.
Some of us are still trying to puzzle out what Pope Francis meant in his most baffling moments. Earlier popes taught that any sexual union outside a legitimate marriage prevents partners from receiving the sacraments. But Francis’ 2016 Amoris laetitia, “On Love in the Family,” emphasizes a process of couples consulting their parish priest in a penitential context, such as confession. In a widely-discussed footnote, he mentions that some such partners might get help from the Church via the sacraments. How this all held together was never clear.
Holiness and weakness
Francis didn’t always aim at controversy. His shorter 2018 exhortation, Gaudete et exsultate, “On the Call to Holiness in Today’s World,” expresses a mainstream consensus, beautifully wrought for the contemporary world, on how Jesus wants his followers to live.
For most of us, holiness means patience with family, kindness to neighbors, working first for the common good rather than our own interests. Our life is a mission, a way for God to speak his word of love to the world. For this, we need both prayerful devotion and a commitment to serve others. Holiness requires sacrifice, but leads to the vitality and joy of becoming the family God created us to be.
Francis was often scorned for his initiative concerning “synodality,” which is meant to express that the relationship of learning and trust between the hierarchy and the laity must be a two-way street. As Francis understood it, synodality is essentially a listening exercise, albeit in a distinctively Catholic way: responsive to the traditions of the Church, drawing in people of every sort, and oriented toward making God’s love known to them. So far as I can tell, the widespread fear of listening proves that Francis was right to say we needed this new approach.
Francis was not flawless. When in 2021 he restricted traditionalists’ access to the older former of Mass, he did not adequately distinguish the needy from the malicious. Francis may also have failed in those whom he chose to trust. Like many of us, he was perhaps overly fond of those who flattered him or who made it clear they’d be loyal to him more than to the truth. Church “insiders” have many complaints about Francis’ choices of an inner circle.
At his worst, Francis hurt victims of sexual abuse, especially those victimized by clergy, by so tritely dismissing some complaints. I can partly understand Francis’ mistakes. He wanted to eliminate sex abuse, yet often confused such efforts with sexual puritanism, which he also wanted to eliminate. But to understand is not to excuse. I can sympathize also with those who abandoned the Catholic family because of how callously he scorned abuse survivors in Chile, for example.
The world’s pastor
Francis’ mistakes were real. But then again, that’s what he meant when upon his election as Pope, he said: “I am a sinner, but I trust in the infinite mercy and patience of our Lord Jesus Christ.” The good news of Jesus Christ includes the promise that our failures die with us when we share fully in the death of the Lord, but we rise with him as the saints he intended us to be.
I loved Francis for sharing with me that trust and hope of the Christian life. Most of us remember his most vivid moment as the world’s pastor on March 27, 2020. Then, at the height of the COVID pandemic, Francis stood in an empty Saint Peter’s square and imparted Jesus’ blessing to the world. On that day he lived up to his lifelong mission to share hope in Jesus as our sure anchor.
Most of all, I loved Francis because he was the Pope, the man the Holy Spirit gave our generation as our father in the Church. God wishes us to honor all fatherhood as something that takes its name from our heavenly Father: a preparation for us as sons and daughters alongside the Son in a family of eternal life and love.
David Poecking is a priest of the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.