Right now, liberal arts education is under siege from almost every direction. Parents don’t want their kids to major in history or philosophy; universities, including my own, are gutting programs in favor of STEM fields; and right-wing politicians think the whole enterprise of the liberal arts is un-American.
Maybe this problem started with Benjamin Franklin.
Useful vs. ‘ornamental’
In writing a proposal for what would become the University of Pennsylvania in 1749, Franklin drew a distinction between knowledge that was “useful” and that which was “ornamental.” American education has been wrestling over that distinction ever since.
“Useful” seems easy enough nowadays to justify. The way we talk about the purpose of higher education now is that it should prepare you for a job. So any major that does that is useful: computer science, “data analytics,” marketing, to take just three examples.
Useful was at the heart of the creation of land grant universities starting in the 1860s, including Penn State (1863). Universities like these trained engineers and agricultural specialists (the A&M/A&T schools) and later, allied health practitioners, accountants, teachers and more.
Studying something “ornamental,” on the other hand, sounds like a frivolous endeavor, the opposite of useful, and not something that is going to lead to a job. Literature and languages, philosophy, and yes, even history.
Back in 2014 President Barack Obama told a crowd, “I promise you, folks can make a lot more, potentially, with skilled manufacturing or the trades than they might with an art history degree.”
But there are two problems with our current view of what is useful and what so many dismiss as merely ornamental, both rooted in misunderstanding what the liberal arts are.
Two problems
First, the data simply don’t support it. Study after study has shown that students who major in the liberal arts do just as well on the job market as those with other majors, especially when measured over time.
The University of Colorado, Boulder, to take one example, did a study in 2022 tracking incomes by major over a ten year period. At the top of the list? History majors, followed by philosophy majors. Business majors, on the other hand, were in the bottom half of the graph.
And that’s no surprise. Narrowly focused training may land graduates a job right out of college, but the job market is shifting and changing constantly. Students who graduate this year will have five to seven jobs, on average, by the time they retire.
A liberal arts training, with its emphasis on critical thinking, persuasive speaking and writing, synthesizing information to ask probing questions are the skills employers value most of all. In other words, over time marketing majors wind up working for philosophy and physics majors.
The second misunderstanding we have about the liberal arts is potentially more consequential. Education in a democratic society has never been simply, or even primarily, about job training.
As everyone from Thomas Jefferson to the philosopher John Dewey has noted, education is about training citizens to participate in our democracy. The land grant universities were established in the 19th century with exactly this goal in mind. The motto of Ohio State University, where I used to teach, is “Education for Citizenship,” not “Education for a Job.”
Here too the liberal arts are crucial and for many of the same reasons that liberal arts majors do well in the economy. I tell my own history students that as citizens we are asked to make choices about the future. But the only way to understand fully where we are today is to understand what happened yesterday, or a decade ago, or a century or longer ago.
Wisdom and courage
In fact, Franklin’s vision back in 1749 was precisely to teach both the useful and the ornamental. Two centuries later, President Dwight D. Eisenhower echoed Franklin almost exactly.
In a speech he gave in 1957, he said: “What will then be needed is not just engineers and scientists, but a people who will keep their heads and, in every field, leaders who can meet intricate human problems with wisdom and courage. In short, we will need not only Einsteins and Steinmetzes, but Washingtons, and Emersons.”
We cheat our students and our nation if we continue to neglect the Washingtons and Emersons.
Steven Conn is the W.E. Smith Professor of History at Miami University in Oxford, Ohio, and author of “The Lies of the Land,” on the myth of rural America, and “Nothing Succeeds Like Failure,” a history of business schools.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.