Whenever I took fabric to the cutting counter at Joann Fabrics, the crafts superstore, the employee in charge would ask me what I was making. “A quilt,” I’d say, or “a skirt” and then I’d chatter away about the joys of sewing for a few minutes. Eventually, I realized that the poor woman was not actually interested and was in fact required to ask.

But still, it was nice. In a world that offers so many mass-produced things, and so many places to sell them to us, Joann’s, as everyone I know familiarly calls the chain, was the big box store that helped people make something uniquely theirs, usually on the cheap. “Assembly required” might have been their slogan.

A few months back, I noticed that the employees had stopped asking what I was going to use my new fabric for, and I realized that the desire to be friendly, corporately-dictated as it was, had ceased. They were shutting down.

Help in making

Mourning a chain store may seem odd, but I do, because Joann’s was nearly singular in its facilitation of making, especially for those of us on a budget. It was a store nearly unique in requiring our participation: our vision, our skills, our five hours of gluing sequins onto off-the-rack sneakers, as I once did. We were not just the consumers, but the co-creators.

Advertise with us

Online maker groups are full of discussion about why a chain that popular — poorly run as it sometimes seemed — could be closing. The answer seems to be, in brief, capitalism, hand-in-hand with the behemoth of Amazon, where I confess, I, too, have discovered pillow forms and embroidery floss sold for less money.

For me, Joann’s was always a place to think and imagine. I grew up going there with my mother and grandmother, usually in search of a particular item that Mum-mum needed for her many beautiful sewing projects. As a kid, I’d follow them around the store, my eyes exactly at the level of the bolts of fabric. There was so much scope for my imagination there.

When I grew up, went to college, and learned that there was a Joann’s a few miles away from my dorm, ambling around it became a way to mull over various life choices without exactly thinking much. I don’t recall anyone ever stopping me. It was a store for daydreaming, perhaps uniquely so.

I cross-stitch, embroider, paint (badly), knit, quilt, and sew, and over the years have tried various one-offs like wood-chip carving, crocheting, and decoupage.

Joann’s was always the first stop for my making, the only store where I could afford yards of fabric for much of my life, the best local source for a bottle of paint, a handful of brushes, a sheet of stickers, or whatever else I might have decided my next project needed. Their price point allowed me the freedom to fail, and keep trying, and get better.

Advertise with us

In the years since college, I have made many, many things, quilts and pillows and sweaters and socks and more. My skills have improved, greatly, and I gain a lot of satisfaction from making. Not all of my materials came from Joann’s. I’ve bought yarn in Ireland, fabric in London, and quilting tools in New York. I’m lucky enough to have the income to do so now.

Inherently good

But the inspiration, those first walks through the colorful aisles, the idea that if you couldn’t find what you wanted you could make it yourself, the price point that allowed the freedom to explore, the chance to step away from the perplexing problems of life and instead think about the simpler question of which pattern to use, all of that came from or through Joann’s.

None of that can be recreated at a laptop screen. Online shopping has never once reminded me of Mum-mum and her belief that making things was inherently good, both for the maker and her recipient.

I stopped by the Monroeville Joann’s last weekend, finding it emptying. The big box bones of the store were exposed, and it no longer felt like a place I might wander. But as I quickly scooped up a package of batting, I overheard two women talking about a bolt of fabric one had found.

“What are you going to make with that?” the other asked.

Advertise with us

“I don’t know,” the other replied. “I guess I’ll find out.”

Shannon Reed is a teaching associate professor and director of the undergraduate studies writing program at the University of Pittsburgh.