I’m leaving two jobs that I genuinely enjoy: Allegheny County Council councilman and chairman of the Republican Committee of Allegheny County. Those jobs were my education in how politics and governance intersect and, more importantly, diverge. They allowed me to be a voice of caution when it came to government overreach and unrealistic expectations.
It is said that the road to hell is paved with good intentions. In the case of government, the paving bill lands on the taxpayers.
Departing for a new job, this one serving Pennsylvania’s newly elected United States senator, I offer a few words of advice.
Compassion and complexity
Even compassion demands basic math skills. One of the most troubling aspects of county government is our seeming inability to master budgeting. Handing out pay raises on the first day in office, pledging to provide more in coming negotiations, and expanding spending across the board in the face of a budget shortfall is akin to spotting a cliff and hitting the gas.
That is why I voted against the current administration’s 36% increase in property taxes. Overspending on lavish salaries for senior staff while promising a welfare state that keeps people dependent on public largesse is unsustainable.
Ask a county homeowner what their tax dollars do for them and they’ll be hard pressed to answer. Right now, they see county government as the Department of Spending.
Simply put, we don’t have the money for expanded programs and we’re not likely to have it by raising taxes in ways that drive homeowners and businesses across the county line. Government has a responsibility to help those in need. It has a moral obligation to do so without creating more of them.
Respect solves complex problems. Sometimes, it’s good to be dull. Right now, we have too many people in office who can’t sleep well if they haven’t seen themselves on the evening news. Sitting on county council taught me that conflict makes better headlines than policy.
Antics and name-calling have come to characterize public life in our country. Allegheny County might be someplace special, but when it comes to pointless conflict and angry rhetoric, we are like most other places in America: caught up in a political arena where sound travels faster than light.
There is no need to name names here, nor does either party lay exclusive claim to this bad habit. But going forward, a good rule of thumb would be not to say anything you wouldn’t want to read on the front page of the next day’s newspapers.
It’s not all bad. I like to think that a bright spot was the 2023 vote for County Executive. Despite a 2-to-1 Democratic edge, Joe Rockey talked policy with a depth of understanding born of years as an expert in finances and someone who didn’t just talk about the homeless. He built them a shelter.
Rockey’s heartbreakingly close loss in that race deprived Allegheny County of a visionary leader but sent a clear message that the Republican Party has something to offer a region where so many now feel abandoned by leaders more interested in retaining power for special interests than in using it for the common good.
The lesson here is that candidate quality matters, and quality candidates are the ones able to articulate the issues that connect with voters.
Republican future
A lesson for Republicans. This brings us to what lies ahead for Republicans in Allegheny County. Political affinities are changing in ways that tell me the next generation won’t be wedded to their parents’ political registrations.
That 2-to-1 Democratic registration edge means it’s tough for Republicans to win countywide, but we are still the single, largest source of Republican votes in the commonwealth. That’s why national and statewide Republican candidates come here. Soon enough, they’ll have countywide officials of their own party to welcome them.
Private sector unions and blue-collar workers feel themselves shut out by a Democratic Party in thrall to its left wing. Younger voters aren’t afraid to call themselves conservatives. Catholic voters, once immovably Democratic, now find themselves comfortable in the GOP, which looks a lot more like the long-ago party that abandoned them.
It’s easy to understand that a party that disallows even the slightest departure from the woke agenda is going to lose the support from working people when it abandons the policies that fed their families and sent their kids to college.
As a party, Republicans need to understand that we cannot multiply by division. Factional disputes grounded in purity tests will not build a Republican Party. The Democrats gave us an example of this danger when thousands of them boycotted the top of their ticket over the Biden administration’s support for Israel.
You don’t win elections by boycotting your candidates. And you don’t build parties by driving out your centrists.
Three years ago, the Allegheny County Republican party faced a similar issue when hardliners attempted to seize control. It would have meant driving away traditional, middle-road Republicans and the independent voters without whom we cannot win. Coalitions win. Factions do not.
Grew up here
I grew up in this town, the grandchild of immigrants who came here from Abruzzi, Italy, and never looked back. I played baseball on dusty sandlots, had my First Communion in my Italian Catholic church, and could name the Pirates’ starting lineup every spring.
My only time living away was my years serving in the Marine Corps. I came back because this isn’t just where I’m from — it’s who I am.
Both of my parents were Democrats. My mom, in fact, was a committeewoman who helped elect Pete Flaherty, a man today’s Democratic Party would probably spurn. My dad was a Teamster. Neither one would be uncomfortable in the Republican Party, which is fast becoming the voice of blue-collar, socially conventional people who feel lost in the current hothouse of American politics.
At every one of my swearings-in, I told the story about my mom’s mom. My grandmother. She was a cleaning woman at the City County Building.
On Fridays my mom would take me Downtown to see my grandmother, who’d take me to work with her before taking me to stay with her for the weekend. It was a humble job for a good woman whose grandson became councilman-at-large in the government that employed her. I like to think that she is now smiling down on me.
All the same, I know that if she’s watching, she might worry about her country and the county she served without complaint.
We need to do better. And we can.
Sam DeMarco was until this month Republican Chairman of Allegheny County and an at-large member of Allegheny County Council. He is Sen. Dave McCormick’s southwestern Pennsylvania regional director. Former Senator Bob Casey has also been asked to write.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.