When John Fetterman told Jonathan Karl on ABC’s “This Week” that “if you’re rooting against the president you are rooting against the nation,” my initial reaction to the Senator’s words was positive.
He seemed to be reminding us that the fate of the nation is more important than the outcome of an election. Hoping Trump’s presidency fails was tantamount in his opinion to hoping the nation fails.
Upon further reflection, I think he was wrong.
Trump’s real best interest
What would a successful Trump presidency mean? Would it mean, as it does for Trump, the deportation of 11 million undocumented immigrants, many of whom have lived here peacefully for decades and most of whom are not violent criminals?
More fossil fuel production and ignoring the threat climate change poses? An isolationist foreign policy in which America turns its back on our NATO partners, plays patty cake with Putin, and lets Xi Jinping bully Taiwan?
I can, however, imagine a successful Trump presidency. It would require Trump to do something in his best interests, if he only recognized it.
Rather than obsessing about winning and punishing his critics, Trump should focus on the one issue that should be of maximum importance to him: his legacy. How does he want to be remembered?
Does he want to be remembered with respect and admiration or with contempt and derision? Fondly like Reagan or harshly like Nixon? As a president who healed the divisions in the country or one who tore it further apart?
Trump is in an ideal position to change. He can reach out to voters who never supported him without worrying about the political consequences. He doesn’t have to worry about his base defecting because he doesn’t need them anymore.
Trump has reached political nirvana, the promised land, a place where polls, voters, donors don’t exist because elections don’t exist. He’s free to be whoever he wants to be. Hallelujah! Praise the Lord!
A successful Trump presidency would be one where he makes his opponents his accomplices, where he works with Democrats to pass landmark legislation. I’m envisioning policies that Democrats have long sought that Trump could co-opt for himself. He would be taking a page out of Bill Clinton’s playbook. In the 1990s, he got credit for long sought Republican efforts to balance the budget, reform welfare and get tougher on crime.
Every Democratic priority that Trump advanced would be a win for him. Lower healthcare costs. Check. Challenge Big Pharma. Check.
Thumb his nose at the fossil fuel industry and become a champion for clean energy. Check. Solve the crisis in the Middle East by working with Saudi Arabia to come up with a two state solution for the Israelis and Palestinians. Check.
Even give the Dreamers a pathway to citizenship. (Even his base mostly don’t want to send back people who’ve lived here all their lives.) Check.
Deep down, I suspect, Trump has no desire to be despised by half the country, even though he’ll exploit their opposition to excite his own supporters. He’s addicted to adulation.
He won two elections largely because his MAGA base stayed loyal to him. Why not govern in this, his last go round, by appealing to voters who never liked him? I don’t think he really enjoys being hated. He’d much prefer being loved.
More magnanimous Trump
I would like to see a kinder, gentler, more magnanimous version of Trump emerge over the next four years. Wouldn’t it be wonderful if he lost his persecution complex, ditched his combative temperament, refrained from calling the press “fake news”?
He can afford to be Mr. Nice. He doesn’t need to be Mr. Nasty. He could extend the olive branch to his bitter rivals in the Democratic Party. He could shake Adam Schiff’s hand, hug Elizabeth Warren, kiss Nancy Pelosi.
Okay, that’s taking it a bit too far. My bad. I allowed my hope for America’s future to run amok.
Jay Wissot is a columnist for the Vail Daily in Vail, Colorado, and occasional contributor to the Post-Gazette.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.