The night of Dec. 5, 1933, passed unusually quietly in Pittsburgh, according to the newspapers. There were no crowds on the streets and police reported few arrests.

Other than a few champagne toasts in some of the more upmarket hotels and restaurants, there wasn’t much evidence to suggest that at precisely 5:32 p.m., for the first time in nearly 14 years, alcohol was legally available to purchase in the city.

Thus ended with a whimper one of the strangest chapters in American history. President Herbert Hoover called Prohibition a “great social and economic experiment, noble in motive and far-reaching in purpose,” yet by 1933 it was so discredited its repeal did not even merit the day’s headline.

To the extent this episode is invoked in popular memory the lesson is most often left only at this: You cannot legislate morality. But this is the wrong lesson to draw from it.

Advertise with us

No agreement on morality

This newspaper wryly observed that arrests for intoxication were lower on the first night after repeal of the Eighteenth Amendment than were normal for the average night during Prohibition.

It further observed that public interest centered more on the forthcoming system of state liquor stores, set to open the following January, and the high price of liquor, than the immediate availability of beer, cocktails and wine.

The Pittsburgh Press, meanwhile, welcomed repeal but implored its readers to drink responsibly, arguing that social custom was a far better regulatory tool to govern alcohol consumption than any law.

The temperance movement spanned the ideological spectrum. While it originated in an unlikely alliance between the progressive movement and religious fundamentalism, there was no agreement on the morality it intended to enforce. The movement garnered support from socialists and factory owners, from Southern Baptist backwoods preachers and New England’s WASP elite.

This great federal government infringement into Americans’ personal liberties was overseen by Calvin Coolidge, now beloved by small government conservatives. Its fiercest public opponent was New York’s governor Al Smith, the nation’s leading social-reforming progressive governor.

Advertise with us

It was a cause initially associated with the feminist suffragette movement who saw in it the potential to strengthen family life and remedy domestic violence. But it soon became identified with the Ku Klux Klan, who cynically used it to rally opposition to immigrants, specifically the more than 25 million largely Catholic, Orthodox and Jewish newcomers who had arrived over the previous five decades.

For this reason, opposition to it was most pronounced in urban communities, and leading Catholic bishops forcefully condemned compulsory prohibition.

Good governance

The relation between morality and law is complex, but this much is certain: All law enforces someone’s idea of morality. Moreover, laws shape society for good or ill.

The Prohibitionists believed that you can legislate morality. But many of Prohibition’s most zealous opponents would have been equally shocked at the assertion that morality cannot be legislated.

Even as they denounced Prohibition’s overreach, they continued to argue for robust social legislation on clear moral grounds.

Advertise with us

Immediately adjacent to the editorial welcoming repeal, for instance, the Press endorsed Pennsylvania governor Gifford Pinchot’s program of social reform in intensely moral language. The issue, the editorial stated, is “drawn with unmistakable clarity.”

The legislature must act on the progressive Republican’s plan to enact state laws prohibiting child labor, protecting women from working “cruel hours for starvation wages” and ending the brutality of company-paid thugs bloodying Pennsylvania’s coal fields.

The forces of reaction had for too long “killed social legislation with brutal unconcern.” But, the Press argued, times had changed, and the people had been aroused “to the vicious underlying evils of the system under which they live.”

The true lesson of Prohibition isn’t about legislating morality: It’s about legislating prudentially. Prudence is the foundation of good governance. And Prohibition was an astonishing act of imprudence.

Prudence is classically defined as “right reason in action.” It is the virtue of not only discerning what is good but also understanding whether it is wise to pursue that particular good at that particular time — and, if it is, how to do effectively.

Advertise with us

Put another way, it is to ask the question of how a particular policy will work — not in theory, but in practice. How does an idea survive contact with real people, living in community? Does it make life better or worse?

The 18th Amendment and the Volstead Act, which enforced Prohibition, were dramatic examples of imprudence. Prohibition demonstrates how often well-intentioned actors, who see a real evil and want to do good, can make life worse.

We know what happened in Prohibition. It damaged the economy, not just closing the drink industry but hurting all the businesses dependent on it; sharply cut government tax income; made criminals of millions of Americans, undermining respect for the law; and worst of all, created organized crime. And ironically, induced some Americans to drink more than ever.

Prudence and democracy

Prudence is neglected in today’s political discussion. It does not incite crowds or inflame passions. It doesn’t win votes.

But for those seriously interested in the material improvement of people’s lives, prudence should be paramount. But we will never see a political ad campaign in which a candidate described themselves as unusually prudent.

Advertise with us

Lawmakers who reason well often can’t see the most effective methods for promoting the good they seek to attain. Their failure to exercise prudence damages the causes they seek to serve.

In imposing Prohibition, temperance advocates tried to eliminate problems by outlawing a pervasive, deeply rooted feature of life. People enjoyed their beer, and wine, and whiskey. They were natural parts of their lives and culture.

Not understanding that, the Prohibitionists foolishly eliminated alcohol entirely, disrupting communities and social traditions, and thereby created a host of unintended consequences.

America eventually saw the damage the Prohibitionists’s lack of prudence had caused. The ratification of the 21st Amendment, which repealed Prohibition 91 years ago this month, reminds us of the crucial role of prudence in governance.

Let us drink and celebrate responsibly — and let our lawmakers govern with the same sense of responsibility.

Mark Barrett is a Pittsburgh lawyer. He can be reached at markdeclanbarrett@gmail.com.