The pundits tell us that America has never been more divided — urban vs. rural, white collar vs. blue collar, “woke” vs. “MAGA,” liberal vs. conservative, women vs. men.
We hear this line every election cycle, because we have such divisions every election cycle. The framers of our Constitution expected these divisions. They called them “factions.”
Part of democracy
James Madison discussed this problem in the 10th of the Federalist Papers, the newspaper articles written by Alexander Hamilton, John Jay, and James Madison to convince New Yorkers to support the proposed Constitution. He observed that such divisions are endemic to democracy: “Liberty is to faction what air is to fire, an aliment without which it instantly expires.”
So long as we’re free to govern ourselves, we’ll divide ourselves into groups. These groups, Madison said, are “actuated by some common impulse of passion, or of interest, adversed to the rights of other citizens, or to the permanent and aggregate interests of the community.”
We’ll split into factions. The effect of our “common impulses” is made worse by another problem — us. Madison notes that our self-interest, passions, faculties, and property interests lead invariably to divisions in society. “The latent causes of faction,” he reasons, “are thus sown in the nature of man.”
Elections put these stark realities on full display. People pursue unbridled self-interest. They’re driven blindly by passions. They protect their money and property and power and try to accumulate more. They band together for these purposes and pursue them whatever the cost and without regard to the impact on others.
More pointedly, elections are painful because they force us to confront the worst in us because politics brings out the worst in us.
The Framers of our Constitution knew and expected this. Our very need for government is predicated on a dim but honest recognition that we are deeply and inescapably flawed. Government can’t fix this brokenness. (That’s the business of religion and philosophy.) So they tried devising a system to mitigate it.
The Framers put into place checks and balances and procedures to contain and perhaps even harness constructively our brokenness. “Ambition must be made to counteract ambition,” said Madison. And ambition is in no short supply.
Messy democracy
It isn’t pretty to watch this system unfold. It’s messy. Democracy is hard. Every election seems to put our human fallibility under a microscope.
And what we see peering through this microscope is a humanity fraught with failures and shortcomings. We see empty promises, deceit, ambition, avarice, violence, pride, ego, and all those facets of our humanity that we’d rather ignore.
In short, we see ourselves.
Although this confrontation with ourselves tempts us to despair, we should remember that this is precisely why we have our constitutional republic in the first place. Our system is designed to work notwithstanding the ugly parts of human nature. In fact, our system is predicated on this ugliness.
Confronting ourselves this election cycle, it certainly seems that we’re entering a new era in American politics. Familiar political factions are dissolving while unfamiliar ones are emerging.
Democratic norms are being called into question. We have less consensus on fundamental moral and social principles than ever before.
This new political era will test the limits of our democratic institutions. And they will be tested all the more by a president who openly disdains our democratic norms and relishes the company of authoritarian leaders.
“If men were angels,” wrote Madison in Federalist No. 51, “no government would be necessary.” Donald Trump is certainly no angel. He will probably do some damage.
But I don’t think he’s smart or capable enough to dismantle a system designed by people much wiser than him to protect itself against people like him.
Our Constitution has withstood ongoing assaults since the 18th century. If history is any indication, it’ll withstand this one.
But it’s important to note that while our politics may be undergoing sea changes, we the people aren’t. We’re still as messed up as we were when the Constitution was ratified in 1788.
We haven’t failed
We haven’t failed in our American experiment, at least not yet.
This observation may not put people at ease. It’s also not exactly hopeful, but maybe we shouldn’t put so much hope into our politics. The Framers certainly didn’t.
Perhaps the best we can do is put our politics into perspective, much like the Framers did. Maybe then we’ll pass this test.
Then again, maybe not.
Ryan Hrobak serves as general counsel to Saint Vincent College and Archabbey, where he also teaches in the theology department. He lives in Bloomfield with his family.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.