Democracies make lots of mistakes in trying to select competent, ethical, and effective legislators, yet they consistently deliver remarkably good outcomes for their citizens. People in democracies live longer, enjoy more freedoms, are wealthier, and fare better across nearly every measure of well-being that researchers have studied.
We all wish there were less poverty, less crime, better education, and improved health care. But compared to non-democracies both historically and globally, democratic nations consistently excel.
This resilience is no accident. The democratic structure enables countries to withstand and bounce back from the inevitable mistakes of leaders and recover in ways authoritarian regimes often cannot. There are many reasons that democracies are so resilient, but I’ll focus on two here: accountability and procedural justice.
Undoing bad choices
In democracies, when leaders fail — by mismanaging the economy, curtailing freedoms, or engaging in unethical conduct — citizens can replace them. This motivates leaders to work toward the public’s best interest, ultimately creating a government that responds to the needs and values of its people.
In non-democracies, leaders have less incentive to care about the effect that their policies have on their citizens, as they face few consequences for failure. There is no way for the country to easily change direction when the leader has led the country astray.
In the U.S., accountability through peaceful transfers of power has curtailed the worst of corruption and incompetence among our leaders. When accountability is eroded, this corrective power, and the resilience it supports, begins to fade.
Read More
Democracies also benefit from a deep psychological advantage: procedural justice. Research in psychology tells us that people who believe a process is fair are more motivated to work toward the common good, whether that means following laws, paying taxes, or contributing positively to their communities. When citizens trust that their voices count, they feel empowered to participate constructively, even when they disagree with current leaders or policies.
This commitment to the common good underpins a resilient, thriving society. In democracies, everybody gets a say in who our leaders are and what our policies will be. The system is transparently fair, creating trust in society.
This trust, reinforced by regular elections and open debate, fuels democracy’s self-healing power, making it stronger from within. When procedural fairness is undermined, that trust and willingness to sacrifice for the country wanes, weakening the country and its institutions.
For these reasons, among others, democracies can rebound when our leaders make mistakes — and when we make mistakes in choosing our leaders. We vote in better leaders and we work together to solve the problems our leaders aren’t solving.
Why democracies fail
Historically, democracies don’t fail because citizens choose bad leaders. They fail because those leaders undermine democratic structures to solidify their hold on power.
People in power tend to crave more power, and are often tempted to get what they want through extra-democratic means. Around the world and throughout history, democracies become non-democracies with surprising regularity as democratically elected leaders cancel elections, revoke constitutions, and refuse to relinquish power when their terms are complete.
Indeed, this is so common that the Mo Ibrahim Foundation pays leaders of fledgling democracies to step down at the end of their terms. Otherwise very few do, and their democracies end.
And when the democracies end, those countries still often have incompetent leaders who make bad policies, but they no longer have the ability to correct the nation’s course. Instead, the people suffer. Corruption increases, institutions and the economy falter, freedom erodes, and the well-being of citizens declines.
One of the reasons that America has been so successful as a nation throughout its history is because we haven’t had to deal with that. Until 2020.
When Trump pushed the false narrative that the election was “stolen” or “rigged,” he led his base to question the fairness of the process. When he engaged in undemocratic tactics to overturn the election, such as pressuring officials to change outcomes and inciting riots to prevent elections from being certified, he led his opponents to question the fairness of the process.
This election’s choice
Donald Trump’s attempts to cling to power four years ago undermined the belief in procedural justice. His election would undermine it further.
It would also undermine the principle of accountability. His election would tell future generations of politicians that Americans don’t care about democracy and that there are no repercussions for subverting the law and the constitution.
This is why I’ll be voting for Kamala Harris this election, despite the fact that, as a Republican, I disagree with most of her policy positions and am generally unimpressed by her record. America, as a democracy, can recover from any leader’s policy missteps.
But history shows that democracies rarely recover when leaders actively dismantle fair governance and accountability. I don’t particularly want Harris to be my president, but it would be much, much worse to have Trump as my dictator.
Daniel Oppenheimer is a professor of social and decision sciences at Carnegie-Mellon University and co-author of “Democracy Despite Itself: Why a System that Shouldn’t Work at All Works So Well.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.