Alarmingly, the United States appears to be retreating from a vital element of its foreign policy, in a monumental forfeiture of the global leadership and legitimacy that have been the bedrock of American influence for generations.
That element is its use of “soft power,” defined by political scientist Joseph Nye in the late 1980s as the “ability to shape the preferences of others through attraction and persuasion, rather than coercion or payment.”
Historically, the U.S. has excelled at leveraging soft power to shape global policies, from climate accords to international treaties. Yet the government’s recent actions suggest the nation is ceding its role in agenda-setting to nations like China, India, and Saudi Arabia, who are stepping up to fill the void.
Profound realignment
The global political capital once wielded by Washington is now being dispersed among these rising powers, and this transition is not just a temporary phase but a profound realignment of global influence. As the U.S. steps back from multilateral engagements, the long-term implications for its foreign policy and global standing are becoming increasingly clear.
A stark example of this retreat is the U.S. decision to withhold payment of its dues to the United Nations, coupled with discussions in Congress in June about proposed legislation to permanently end U.S. funding for the UN and its affiliated organizations.
By the end of 2023, the UN faced its most severe liquidity crisis in history, largely due to member states — most notably the U.S. — failing to pay their dues in full and on time. This financial strain has real-world consequences, particularly for the vulnerable populations the UN serves and the organization’s ability to maintain global law and order, a system the U.S. has long championed.
Critics of multilateral organizations like the UN argue that bilateral aid is more effective, pointing to inefficiencies within the UN itself. However, there is strong evidence that multilateral aid channels are less politicized, more demand-driven, and better equipped to provide global public goods than bilateral alternatives.
Furthermore, multilateral institutions like the UN offer recipient countries a more equitable distribution of aid, with decisions based on need rather than geopolitical interests. The UN Reforming the UN to make it more efficient is undoubtedly necessary, but withholding funds is not the way to spur those changes.
Doing so not only hinders the UN’s vital work but also diminishes the U.S.’s ability to project soft power, making it harder for Washington to influence the global agenda.
As other nations fill the vacuum left by U.S. disengagement, they are not merely stepping in, they are reshaping the international policy landscape. China, in particular, has invested heavily in its own brand of soft power, using trade, infrastructure, and diplomacy to deepen its influence across Africa, Asia, and Latin America.
Needed cooperation
By contrast, the U.S. seems to be surrendering its leadership role at precisely the moment when global cooperation is most needed.
The upcoming pandemic treaty, the fight against climate change, and efforts to manage global security crises like the Israel-Gaza conflict all require strong U.S. participation and leadership. Yet, recent U.S. actions, such as withholding UN funds and stepping back from international agreements, signal a retreat from these responsibilities.
Politicians who believe the U.S. can simply focus inward while continuing to shape global affairs are deluding themselves. You cannot abandon multilateral engagement and expect to dictate global outcomes from the sidelines.
To maintain its influence and continue setting the terms of global politics, the U.S. must remain fully engaged in the international system. It cannot afford to relinquish its seat at the table while others reshape the global order in their image.
As the election approaches, Americans must recognize the long-term consequences of retreating from soft power. Soft power is not an optional component of U.S. foreign policy—it is a fundamental asset. It forges alliances, encourages cooperation, and upholds the international system that has brought relative stability to the world.
Without it, the U.S. risks becoming a mere observer rather than a leader in global affairs, a position that no great power can afford to occupy.
Monik Bhatta, a graduate of the University of Pittsburgh, has worked in international development for a decade and is currently a student at the Harvard Kennedy School of Government. His previous article was “The world needs to know now what to do about the next pandemic.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.