Two Thursdays ago, I intended to circulate a letter among the Pitt students in the Palestine Solidarity Encampment. But then, I encountered a sign giving the five “camp rules.” The second rule was “Don’t talk to Zionists!” with an arrow pointing to “[expletive] pigs!”

Zionism is the Jewish national movement for self-determination and statehood in the ancestral land of Israel. About 80% of American Jews “say caring about Israel is an essential or important part of what being Jewish means to them.” Near 100% of Israeli Jews are Zionists.

These two groups account for more than four-fifths of all Jews in the world. Most of the remaining Jews probably feel similarly. In short, although Jews and Zionists are different categories, the overlap between Jews and Zionists is overwhelming.

Due to camp rule #2, here comes my second attempt at opening a constructive dialogue, sharing the letter with the wider community in Pittsburgh and beyond. It is written “To each and every Pitt student in the Palestine Solidarity Encampment and beyond,” and in-vites them to a dialogue in which we each challenge some of each assumptions and assertions and com-mend others.

Advertise with us

Neither should have happened

I read in agreement your slogan calling for an immediate cease fire. The killing of innocent civilians in Gaza should have never happened. But why does not the encampment demand the immediate release of all hostages? Isn’t the release of the abductees a core human rights concern to you?

These abductions, alongside the murders, attempted murders, rapes, and torture of civilians in Israel should have never happened in the first place either, and that happened when Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad broke the ceasefire.

You call for the end of genocide. What the Israeli army is doing in Gaza is indeed a humanitarian nightmare that must be ended. The International Court of Justice ruled that Israeli actions, “would exponentially increase what is already a humanitarian nightmare with untold regional consequences,” but it did not rule that genocide was being committed.

The Genocide Convention of 1948 defined genocide as “acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group.” This is what Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad perpetrated on Oct. 7, 2023.

How about calling also for the end of Hamas’s genocidal intentions? For example, Hamas spokesman Ghazi Hamad declared on Oct. 24 of last year that: “We must teach Israel a lesson, and we will do it [Oct. 7] twice and three times. … On Oct. 7, Oct. 10, Oct. one-millionth, everything we do is justified.” Don’t you see in the massacre perpetrated by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad a crime against humanity?

Advertise with us

You strive for a Free Palestine. That has been my call too for decades. That is, a free Palestine alongside a free Israel. Sharing this narrow land between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea is the way to go. Our shared foes are those, Jews and Palestinians alike, claiming the entirety of the land, from the river to the sea, for themselves only.

One may think of territorial partition as unjust, given that the Palestinians represented the local society while the Jews represented the foreign one under Ottoman and British Rule. Much can be said and discussed on that. But a couple of things are clear.

First, Jewish settler colonialism in the land of Palestine/​Israel is not the standard prototype of settler colonialism, which is a cohort of people sent and supported by an expanding metropole.

The British Empire is the most plausible metropole backing this presumed colonial movement. But its stance was always ambivalent. It granted the Balfour Declaration in 1917 and suppressed the Palestinian Revolt in 1936 to 1939, but it also banned Jewish migration, starting in 1939, and since 1944 fought the Jewish military organizations in Palestine.

Far from representing a colonial empire, Jewish settlers came out of a marginalized and persecuted minority with a history, heritage, and culture tied to the land of Israel/​Palestine. Conversely, the local society, the Palestinian nation, which coalesced as a nation at some point between the 1830s and the 1910s, is the inheritors of the Arab settler colonialism that conquered the land in the 7th century CE and has been settling it since.

Advertise with us

Two communities

Second, today, between the river and the sea there are more than 9.5 million Israeli citizens and 5.5 million Palestinians. Call the first (or the 73.2% among them who are Jewish) the descendants of the ancient Hebrews, of the Israelites, or of the Zionist colonists. Call the latter the descendants of the ancient Canaanites, of the Arab settlers, or of the indigenous population.

It should not matter. At the end, there are two communities in the land that equally deserve their human rights, civil rights, and right of self-determination.

A partition of the land as proposed in 1937 by the Peel Commission would have offered the Jews a refuge on the eve of the Holocaust. The materialization of the partition plan sanctioned by the UN in 1947 would have precluded the ensuing war and Nakba.

The failure of the attempted partition at the 2000 Camp David Summit triggered the Second Intifada, which cost the lives of more than 5,000 people, the majority of which were civilians. (This is the alleged “only one solution” proclaimed in far too many campuses, i.e., “the Intifada revolution”).

Since then, the Israeli and Palestinian societies have been spiraling into radicalization. This enthroned Benjamin Netanyahu in power for a major part of the last 25 years, together with his ever more ethno-religious-nationalistic and authoritarian coalitions. The worst of these has been ruling Israel since the end of 2022.

Advertise with us

Gaza has been under the rule of Hamas since 2007. Designated a terrorist organization by many states, Hamas’s ISIS-like behavior was tragically on display on Oct. 7. The majority of the Palestinians in the West Bank, according to several surveys, seem to support Hamas.

In short, the failure to partition the land and establish two viable states has perpetuated and worsened the conflict. The way to resolve the conflict remains the co-existence of two states with leaders who firmly acknowledge the rights of their counterparts and infuse these sentiments in their respective societies.

One-sided or comprehensive?

So, what stance should you take at this moment? A one-sided one in which some human rights count and others don’t? One in which you denounce some atrocities and turn a blind eye on others? Wouldn’t a comprehensive approach in which all human rights count be better?

And while asserting the right of a nation to freedom, shouldn’t you acknowledge the right of the other too? Yes, you should, because exclusivism and displacement are at the core of this conflict, while mutual recognition is at the core of its prospective resolution.

And when a rightful cause, as the Palestinian struggle for self-determination, is led by a terrorist organization, shouldn’t you make the distinction by embracing the cause and repudiating that leadership?

Advertise with us

There is much more to be unpacked in the Palestine Solidarity Encampment slogans, banners, and mission statement. I am still thinking that within this encampment there are students willing to think and communicate freely beyond the discriminatory constraints imposed by the organizers. What is college education good for if not for that?

Diego Holstein, author of “A Brief History of Now,” is a professor of history at the University of Pittsburgh.