Grief and loss. Sadness. Rejection. Trauma. Some of us experience these on occasion. Some people experience these emotions all the time and all at once.
I work out of Second Avenue Commons, the city’s relatively new low-barrier shelter that serves people experiencing homelessness. My official title is behavioral health therapist, but my role includes crisis intervention, client advocacy, social work, and activity coordination.
Most importantly, I am a vessel for the wrenching stories my clients need to share. Some tell me they have never told their stories, which often share common themes, before meeting me.
Pervasive realities
Grief, loss, sadness, rejection, trauma. These realities are so pervasive in their minds that they become the norm. Any positive emotions they feel are weak and fleeting.
When any of us are in moments of real weakness or stress, we are liable to make choices that lead us down a wrong path — because the path seems to us like a one-way road. And when the problems in our life compound, we feel our fate has been pre-determined.
Now imagine that, because you have nowhere to live, you’re almost always in a state of weakness and stress and your problems keep compounding. The cumulative weight of this seems soul-crushing.
Read More
Take the example of “Carl,” a white male in his early 50s. Carl fell into homelessness about a year ago, when he found out the rent money he was giving his landlord was somehow not actually paying his rent. His landlord then told him to leave for non-payment.
He went down to the winter shelter that formerly operated out of the basement of the Smithfield United Church of Christ. This emergency shelter was one of the only resources in downtown Pittsburgh for people who had nowhere else to go, but was at the same time rife with drug use and other dangers.
One morning someone accused him of stealing their phone. Carl said he did not do it, but it resulted in him being assaulted. Now with a broken nose and several missing teeth, he was carried into our clinic by his girlfriend.
Several years ago they had their young son taken from them by Pittsburgh’s Office of Children, Youth and Families when they lost their home for a few months. Carl was also grieving the recent death of his father during the holidays, along with the passing of his mother several years before from cancer, but he was so consumed with his experience of homelessness and his custody battle over his son that he had no mental bandwidth to truly grieve the loss of both parents.
Carl had struggled with depression and anxiety throughout his life, and now his symptoms were more consistent and intense.
Never a best choice
He then reached out for help from people who he thought were his friends, but their idea of help was to self-medicate with street drugs that ended up being laced with fentanyl, and he overdosed. Now he was trying to get away from those substances and those people. He came to me and said he wanted to take any shortcut possible to get out of his situation.
Many people tell stories like Carl’s, stories that are so complex and ridden with challenges. How do I respond?
Do I suggest to Carl an intensive outpatient treatment program, for someone might be ready to treat their substance abuse and their underlying mental illness at the same time? Do I suggest rehab?
In either case, am I considering that he may have been so invalidated by the system that any roadblock along the way will cause him to fall back into his familiar patterns that led to his current situation? Or do I tell him to stick with me, when it is possible I cannot prevent him from falling back into those familiar patterns?
What is the best choice for clients like Carl? As I have learned, there is never a best choice. There are choices that have better odds of better outcomes, but there are no magic bullets to rid someone of a bad situation.
As a counselor, I take the word “best” to mean that I will not always suggest the best choice for people like Carl, but they will know I am trying my best. Another word I lean on is “trust.” If my clients can trust that I am consistently working for them, they might forgive me when my work does not magically erase their problems.
People begin to trust me when I hold space for them – not to recoil from them, or minimize their problems, or suggest quick fixes. Just sit and listen. And if my clients can trust me, maybe later they will trust someone else to help them with something that will make their lives incrementally better. From what I have learned over the years, incremental improvements can be enough, because they eventually can lead to significant change down the line.
Prioritizing survival
I am inundated with stories of people falling into mind-bendingly complex situations that are so mentally and physically consuming they can only prioritize what they need now to survive. For those not sure where they will lay their heads tonight, mental health resides near the bottom of their to-do lists.
These are some of the most inspiring, resilient, loving, energetic and honest people I have met in my life. I am honored to serve these brave individuals, which is why it pains me and my colleagues to see so many negative labels placed on them.
From my standpoint it is the system that deserves the negative labels, though I know so many providers like me who are trying their best. I continue to trust I will see days when my best is good enough.
Justin Grotelueschen is the behavioral therapist at the Second Avenue Commons Health Center, in downtown Pittsburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.