The past weeks of horror as I have witnessed from afar the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has triggered so many complex emotions for me. I am a Jew. I am a Pittsburgher. I am a psychologist. I was president of Tree of Life on Oct. 27, 2018.
I like to describe what I often see as parallel truths, because we live in this world where many people like to talk in absolutes and striking dichotomy of right and wrong. I reject the irrational biased hatred of most absolutes.
I have always seen the value of gray, rather than black and white, as the balance in life to me is at its ideal a rainbow, and at its worst shades of gray.
Parallel truths
Even as I struggle internally with two huge pieces of who I am — a liberal American and a Jew, even as my faith flickers in the hurricane of pain, loss, sadness and grief — I know parallel truths.
I know the parallel truths of faith and peace on one hand, and the complexity of my country’s ideal beliefs on the other. I know the truth that Jews and Muslims can live among each other in peace, harmony, kindness and faith. During the most terrifying moments of my life, when I arrived at synagogue 15 minutes late on 10/27/2018, I received that kindness and faith.
The Islamic community of Pittsburgh immediately responded with those attributes. Wasilluh Mohammed, the director of the Islamic Center of Pittsburgh, was ever present at the funerals for Tree of Life, New Light, and D’Or Hadash victims. The Islamic community pledged and provided donations of over a quarter million dollars to help our families and synagogues bury our dead and to recover — matching or exceeding the donations of any Christian denominations (many of whom also gave generously).
The Islamic community of Pittsburgh invited members of the Quebec City Mosque shooting to meet with leaders of the three synagogues for support. Mr. Mohammed, as well as others in the Islamic community, joined the broader Pittsburgh community at Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall on the Sunday following the attack in a memorial service. Many continued to join us at Tree of Life services in solidarity in the weeks and months after the attack.
Solidarity and support
Five months later, on Friday, March 15, 2019, another similar attack occurred on two mosques in Christchurch, New Zealand. The Jewish community immediately responded in an effort to return the same kindness and support. We stood in unison to remember the lives lost, again meeting at Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall.
Our local Jewish community raised over $600,000 for victims and families of the Christchurch attack. We stood outside the mosque in Oakland to show solidarity and offer support so that congregants could feel safe to come and pray.
In turn, on the date of the one-year commemoration of the Tree of Life attack, women and children from the Islamic community walked from the Islamic Center to Tree of Life, singing songs and bringing flowers. Leaders of the Islamic community have continued to participate in commemoration activities and programs to remember lives lost to COVID.
We received so much support from various Protestant, Catholic, Muslim, Hindu and other communities throughout the recovery from the 10/27/2018 attack. I can’t truly put to words the emotion I feel when people, some of whom have been seen as historical antagonists, stand with you — it is the most powerful symbol of courage, faith, unity and hope. When all of those wonderful human beings from our community rose with us, we knew that we could be stronger than hate.
I know I live in Mr. Roger’s neighborhood, and Pittsburgh is a special place. And I truly believe this mutual support and kindness is possible anywhere. Our support of one another may wax and wane; our communities may disagree on issues; and none of us are monoliths with one voice. We were there for each other when it mattered most. I felt that again when I saw Mr. Mohammed at the fifth commemoration event weeks ago.
Complex ideals
I also know the complex ideals of my country. The complexity of America is worthy of a novel that I am not qualified to write. We believe in the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. We are judgmental, narrow-minded and create our truths from selective interpretation of facts. I stand always as an American and believe my country to be a bastion of democracy, despite my felt lack of safety. I believe in my liberal roots that all people have the right to exist and the freedom to self-govern. I believe in the golden rule of treating others as I wish to be treated.
I also know the historic struggles of America in the strife toward equity. I see the complex interplay of the fight for equity and representation play out in America now in competing support and rallies. I see sides in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict believing in absolute truths, and narrow-minded interpretations of history to suit those beliefs.
I will support Israel unequivocally. I will pray for and give to my people. And I will also never forget when in Pittsburgh, Muslims and Jews stood together, in peace and with kindness, and I will have faith that this shall happen again.
I invite us all to search for the rainbow in the gray, to consider the responsibility we carry if we follow the golden rule; what security, dignity, safety, peace and freedom mean for us all.
Samuel K. Schachner is a licensed psychologist practicing in Pittsburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.