In 1830, the forced migration of Tennessee and North Carolina Cherokee and Choctaw Indians out west to the Oklahoma Territory — the “trail of tears” — likely was a dream come true for slaveholding U.S. President Andrew Jackson, who lived for some time with another man’s white wife. But in signing the Indian Removal Act, he could never have anticipated the emergence from it of Sarah Rector.

The complicated backdrop to the little rich Black Indian girl saga began long before Sarah Rector was born in 1902. But the Blacks and Native Americans that the Dawes Roles certified after that westward movement was the pivotal development in her astonishing only-in-America tale.

Coming into wealth

In 1902 Sarah Rector was born in the mostly Black town of Taft in the Oklahoma Territory, then regarded as Indian Territory. She descended from Black freedmen in the Choctaw Nation, one of the so-called “Five Civilized Tribes.” Some of her ancestors were slaves of the Muskogee Creek tribe — another of the “Civilized” — as well. But she also descended from Opothleyahola, the Muscogee chief who had fought in the Seminole Wars.

Advertise with us

Seminoles, Chickasaws, Cherokees, Creeks and Choctaws comprised the quintet regarded as “civilized.” “Civilized” meant that those First Americans intermingled with white Americans and embraced enslavement of African Americans.

Typical audiences would never know it because of the state of 1940s and 1950s Broadway plays and Hollywood movies, but the original Rodgers and Hammerstein musical play and movie “Oklahoma!” — about quarreling white farmers and cowboys — were set in Indian territory. Today, it is the state of Oklahoma.

After the Civil War, Congress established the Dawes Roles, the names upon which were members of the aforementioned tribes and the slaves that they held. The Treaty of 1866 recognized the African Americans of the Creek Nation. And land in the Oklahoma Territory was apportioned to folks and/​or their descendants according to the Dawes Roles.

By the time of her birth in 1902, based on her Muskogee Creek ancestry, the 1866 Treaty between the United States and the Creek Nation as well as the Dawes Roles documentation, Sarah Rector owned a stoney 159-acre parcel of Oklahoma land, about 60 miles from her family home. More arable acreage had been reserved for white settlers and full-blooded Native Americans.

A sadly predictable response

Advertise with us

As was the case with General William Tecumseh Sherman’s more famous Order 15, mandating that freed slaves receive 40 acres (a mule was later added), post-Civil War reparations for Black Indians did not produce many legendary accounts of great wealth, because they did not exist. Sarah Rector was an accident. Her land wasn’t supposed to be that good.

Little Sarah’s father could make no money off the land to pay the annual taxes. So he leased it to John D. Rockefeller’s Standard Oil Company. A wildcatter discovered oil under the child’s land and the wells eventually produced 105,000 gallons of oil a day.

Suddenly, she was independently rich at eight years old. She was so wealthy, the state legislature thought she should have some white privileges African Americans were routinely denied, such as riding in the white section of public conveyances. The American press responded predictably. The Washington Post headlined a story “Oil Made Pickaninny Rich.” It described her as “an orphan, crude, black and uneducated.”

America being America, the rules of the day required that a white trustee — rather than her parents — take charge of the girl’s windfall. A contemporaneous newspaper account in the Black-owned Chicago Defender published an erroneous report that the trustee was mismanaging Sarah Rector’s money and that she and and her family were living in poverty.

Learning of the false reports, the most prominent and influential Black men of the day — adversaries W.E.B. DuBois and Booker T. Washington — got the white trustee arrangement undone.

Advertise with us

The wealthiest Black girl

By 1913, Sarah Rector had an income of more than $300,000 per year. According to Black Enterprise magazine, she was the wealthiest Black girl in the nation by then. At the high point, her net worth reached $14,000,000 in today’s dollars. At 18, she owned a boarding house, a bakery and restaurant, and 2,000 acres of land, as well as investments.

A millionaire preteen, she enrolled in Booker T.’s Tuskegee prep school in Alabama and later in the Tuskegee Institute (Tuskegee University today). She and her family then moved to Kansas City, where she bought a stone house that became known a the Rector Mansion.

At 20, Sarah Rector married and became Sarah Rector Campbell, a philanthropist and socialite in Kansas City, Mo. She and her businessman husband — the second Black man to own a car dealership — had three sons. After the couple divorced, in 1934 she married again and became Sarah Campbell Crawford.

Remaining in Kansas City, she raised her three sons and lived an elegant life, entertaining visiting Black celebrities and entertainers like Joe Louis and Duke Ellington. By the time of her death in 1960, she still had money, though not the great wealth of her youth. The latter was diminished by the Great Depression.

Robert Hill is an award-winning Pittsburgh writer and communications consultant and a regular contributor to the Post-Gazette.