Most of the controversy over how to teach American history today focuses on who did what — on who deserves the credit and the blame for our nation’s past and present.
But often people don’t make their own history: Natural forces and environmental phenomena make it for them. So do infectious diseases. History is also about the “near misses” — the things that almost occurred, and would have mattered, but didn’t.
Take, for instance, the (non-)history of plague in early America.
When England began colonizing the Americas in the early 1600s, its population had only recently recovered from a plague outbreak three centuries ago. Between 1347 and 1352, plague had killed between 25 and 50 million people, sending one-third of all Europeans to their graves in what one paleoecologist calls, “the worst disaster that has ever hit” the continent.
Plague is caused by Yersinia pestis, a ferocious bacterium that normally kills rodents such as rats, and also clogs the tiny foreguts of the fleas that bite them. Desperate to feed, the stricken insects leap from rats to people, regurgitating Y. pestis into the new host’s bloodstream. Shocking symptoms soon follow: fevers as high as 108°, excruciating buboes (inflammations of the lymph nodes) near the groin and armpits and an overpowering stench from the breath and sweat.
In medieval settings where rats, fleas and filth were everywhere, infections could consume great capitals and small villages alike. Fatality rates for bubonic plague reached 50%, but the rarer pneumonic form, which infects the lungs and can spread from person to person, kills 90%.
Smaller versions of the mid-1300s apocalypse went on for centuries. William Shakespeare (1564-1616) was born during a plague outbreak that killed one-third of his native Stratford-upon-Avon. The dread of the pestilence and the despair it inspired is evident in many of his plays, including Romeo and Juliet (“a plague on both your houses!”) and Macbeth (“Life’s but a walking shadow, a poor player, that struts and frets his hour upon the stage, and then is heard no more.”)
Another of Shakespeare’s plays, The Tempest, was partly inspired by a 1609 shipwreck on Bermuda, which became a sister colony to the English settlements in Virginia. It was here that the ancient scourge nearly came to America: In 1620, just before the Mayflower sailed for Cape Cod, a supply vessel called the Joseph limped into Bermuda, having already lost twenty to thirty people to bubonic plague. The survivors were “very crazie” to get off, and the colony’s governor let them ashore.
Evidently, some fleas jumped directly from the sick passengers onto healthy islanders, probably as the rowboats carried the survivors to shore. Some new cases emerged — but only a few, since bubonic plague usually requires infected rats, not infected people, to spread widely.
Bermuda already had rats: About five years before the Joseph arrived, another vessel had introduced them and caused a rodent infestation of Old Testament proportions. But the eight- to ten-week voyage across the Atlantic was so long that incoming rats infected with plague, on the Joseph or any other ship, were dead or sick on arrival.
As Bermuda expert and historian-archeologist Michael Jarvis notes, the island had no wharves in 1620, leaving the Joseph to anchor offshore rather than to tie directly onto a dock. “The rats would need to hitch a ride on the launch boats or to swim a quarter mile over open water,” he explains. As far as we can tell, none did so.
If plague had begun to circulate in Bermuda that year, it could have easily made the week-long trip to Virginia, then a struggling settlement of 1,200 English colonists and nineteen African slaves. Such an outbreak would have finished off that colony, leaving eastern North America to a range of Indian, Dutch, English, French and even Swedish competitors.
Instead, plague never again crossed the Atlantic, marking an essential difference between America and Europe.
From Massachusetts to Georgia, the British colonists expanded, their fertility unbound by space and untouched by Y. pestis. By the 1750s, Benjamin Franklin calculated that the population of the Thirteen Colonies was doubling every 25 years. “What an Accession of Power to the British Empire!”
The demographic boom roared on long after the colonies broke free, making the United States one of the most populous nations in the world by 1900, when plague at last came to America — by way of the Pacific. By then, medical authorities knew to fight the disease by exterminating rats, limiting the outbreak to a few sections of San Francisco.
By contrast, Old World pathogens that largely spared the mostly rural settlers decimated indigenous Americans, killing up to 90% of people with no prior contact with such diseases. A veritable Eden to the European newcomers, America became a vast crypt for its first inhabitants.
The story of the Joseph and of the absence of plague in America invites us to see our past, not as another battleground for our self-important ideologies, but rather as a larger drama, made up of a million details, over which people had little control or even awareness.
In Shakespeare’s terms, we are all poor players on a vast and darkened stage, unseen and unheard by unfeeling fate.
Jason Opal is Professor of History and Faith Wallis is Professor Emerita in the History and Classical Studies and Social Studies of Medicine at McGill University.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.