“The startling thing about Easter is that it’s not all about us,” a friend once said to me. He had grown up in a small New England town in a family that was only nominally Christian. His parents did not attend church even on Christmas or Easter.
But his mother did dye and hide Easter eggs, and on Easter morning, she dressed him up in his Sunday best and took him into town. The family paraded up and down the main street, as others appeared in their finery and did the same. Easter was all “about us.”
As an adult, he began reading the gospel narratives. He could not put them down. Something touched him, intrigued him, and even perplexed him. He became a Christian, went to seminary, and was called into pastoral ministry.
Now, he and his wife dyed and hid Easter eggs for their kids and dressed them up in their Sunday best on Easter morn. But they went to church, not to town, and he stood in the pulpit to say, “It’s all about God.”
Some Christians have tried to establish the crucifixion and resurrection as historical facts. But this history turns out to be elusive. Yes, there seems to have been a Jesus, and he seems to have been crucified. Yes, there were reports that he appeared to Mary, Peter, and two disciples on the road to Emmaus — or was he merely an apparition?
No one actually saw him rise from the dead. The women found only an empty tomb. Whatever the resurrection is about, it defies our efforts to master it with our tools of observation and analysis.
Read More
Other Christians have regarded the biblical accounts of Holy Week and Easter as great mythology, great because of their penetrating insight into the human condition, mythology because we can never precisely reconstruct the historical events behind them. The gospel writers have elaborated and expanded, interpreted and reframed, creating a remarkable story about evil and good, right and wrong.
An innocent man is condemned to death — have there not been millions of such “crucifixions” in a world of racial and nationalistic hatred? Out of death and disappointment come life and new possibilities — is this not a wise lesson for every human being?
Profound as they are, Holy Week and Easter do not make a satisfying morality tale. The innocent man puts up no defense; indeed, he claims that he chooses to die. The authorities do not so much hate him as find him puzzling, an annoyance more than a threat.
The disciples are almost as clueless. Even before his death, they had complained that he had failed to usher in a promised kingdom in which they would sit at his right and left hand in glory.
The risen Jesus seems to do no better. He goes ahead of them to Galilee, leaving behind no new strategies for social justice or world peace. Life soon returns to the all too ordinary: work, play, love, resentment, happiness, sadness, and ultimately death.
In recent years, some Christians have tried to find their way out of the perplexity of Holy Week and Easter by embracing mystery. Since we cannot make rational sense of the events, perhaps it is best just to let the gospel story be, with all of its strange, otherworldly edges.
Sometimes Jesus seems human — he weeps for his deceased friend Lazarus. Then, as though divine, Jesus raises him from the dead. Jesus casts demons out of a troubled man but asks him to say nothing about it. Jesus takes bread, prays, breaks it, and distributes it, and there is more than enough for five thousand hungry men on a grassy hillside.
Jesus’ words are no less mysterious. “I am the bread of life,” “I am the good shepherd,” “I am the way, the truth, and the life.” We listen but are not certain that we understand. We look at this man, this Son of God, and wonder where his (or our) life has come from or where his (or our) death will take us. The Gospels and their Jesus draw us into a mystical reality, in but not of this world.
But when we simply revel in the mystery of these events, we avoid their demand on us. Embracing mystery tempts us to pack the crucifixion and the resurrection safely away into an inner space where they no longer trouble us.
In contrast, the Gospels claim that the risen Jesus asks us to change our orientation toward life and death completely. He will not let us off the hook.
No, Holy Week and Easter are not all about us. They establish no reliable history to prove the Christian faith. Their insights into the human condition bring us up short; something here eludes us. We encounter mystery, but our wonder and awe are all too indistinguishable from fantasy and illusion.
Because we are unable to figure out anything else, Easter becomes Easter eggs and candies, colorful bonnets, and brand-new suits and dresses. For a society that is increasingly “post-Christian,” even they soon become nothing more than quaint traditions that people take or leave.
The point of the gospel narratives is different. They declare a reality beyond our human realities, a truth beyond our fumbling, fragmentary truths, and a sense to what seems humanly senseless. Many Christian traditions observe Holy Week with readings of the long passion narratives. The Eastern Orthodox churches, which will observe Holy Week next week, read from all four Gospels.
The words pour over us — too many to take in — until to our surprise we find ourselves with Judas, kissing Jesus; with the soldiers, mocking him; with the crowds, crying out, “Crucify him”; with Peter, hearing the cock crow; and with Mary and the women, keeping watch at the cross on Good Friday and three days later at the tomb at daybreak.
In its telling of Jesus’ last days, the Gospel of Mark lays down this refrain, “Watch.” Do not look at yourself, do not ask what the story is supposed to do for you — just keep watch. My friend says that as a pastor that too was all he knew to say to his congregation on Easter morning, “Watch.”
It seems such a little thing, but it is enough, more than enough. Watch for the One to whom alone you belong. Watch, he is coming to you. Watch, and when you least expected it, you too may suddenly proclaim — in fear and trembling, joy and acclamation — “He is risen; he is risen, indeed.”
That, you see, is what it is all about.
John P. Burgess is professor of theology at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.