For years Ken Petri — like a lot of long time Pittsburghers — shopped at the Giant Eagle grocery store located near his home in Ross Township. That tradition came to a halt a few years ago when the grocer made a real estate purchase just before a Walmart was set to dot the I’s and cross the T’s to break ground on Blazier Drive in McCandless. The locally owned chain purchased a major chunk of the land the Walmart was supposed to sit on.
“That was it for me,” said Petri. “Walmart would have been a viable choice for a supermarket for many families on a budget to use, but a big competitor to Giant Eagle, so they essentially squashed the project by buying a small plot of land and killing the deal.”
Petri, a businessman, said for him Giant Eagle has gone from the once beloved neighborhood “Iggle” to a big business out of touch with its customers. “From their high prices to trying to become the largest supermarket monopoly in the region, that’s just not who they were,” Petri said.
He now drives from Ross Township to either Cranberry or Moon Township to shop at Walmart — “50 percent on principle, 50 percent on lower prices,” he said.
In multiple interviews with shoppers across Western Pennsylvania, people had remarkably candid and strident views about where they shopped for food — something that should not come to too much of a surprise given how parochial we are in this region — with the strongest opinions resting on price and which grocer had dipped too much into national politics for their taste.
As one shopper put it, as she strolled her two-year-old in the shopping cart of a local Shop and Save: “I don’t want to be lectured to by my grocery store about politics or climate change or social justice, or have to bring bags because other people litter with theirs — so I shop here and several other places.” She was referencing Giant Eagle’s decision to gradually stop stocking plastic bags for their customers.
Read More
The mother of three says the grocer does not walk the walk. “This seems to be something you say to make your friends on social media applaud you; when is the last time they had a grocery store in the Hill District?”
Giant Eagle spokesman Dick Roberts said the company has waived their delivery fees for online orders from the Hill District and that they deliver hundreds of orders every month. Other communities facing “food-access challenges” benefit, including Sheraden, Larimer, Homewood West, Homewood South, Mt. Oliver, Manchester, Rankin, and Braddock. “Giant Eagle Mobile Market is one small, hopeful step towards positively impacting social justice in our communities.”
Giant Eagle’s local roots are deep. The company’s progression from a multi-family owned local grocer with its first store in Brentwood to megagrocer spread across Western Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indiana, Maryland and West Virginia has been far from an overnight success; print ads from the early days showed a local grocery trying to attract shoppers with low prices.
By 1941 — five years after Giant Eagle opened its first store on Brownsville Road — the company had expanded its footprint to modest working-class neighborhoods in the city and in blue-collar river towns where industry was booming. Those included Manchester, Donora, Millvale, Sharpsburg, Coraopolis, Ambridge, Turtle Creek, East Pittsburgh, Warrington Avenue and East McKeesport.
Giant Eagle print ads in the Post-Gazette and Sun-Telegraph were cheerful, focused on quality and pricing, and were usually paired in the food section with recipes from food writers. Back then, the closest thing they ever came to broaching the line of politics — and this is a stretch — were tag lines urging the purchase of war bonds during World War II.
In the beginning, Giant Eagle’s local competitors were A&P, Kroger, Thorofare and Schwartz Sanitary; an examination of ads for the next several decades shows a brand focused on customers saving money. Whether it was a Blue Stamp program or a “Marked Difference” campaign or “Absolute Minimum Pricing” program — which led to a rather nasty price war with Super Dollar stores in the 1980s — the message Giant Eagle presented to the public was that you saved money when you shopped there.
It was in the company’s 50th year that Giant Eagle transformed from “local grocer” to a “one stop shop” for all of your needs. It added pharmacies banks, flower shops, greeting cards and gift wrapping departments, film development, gas pumps and video rentals. The stores grew to upwards of 106,000 square feet.
It was in the 80s — when Kroger abruptly left the region during a prickly labor dispute — that Giant Eagle picked up a significant percent of the market share, still managing to keep its nose out of politics and its prices down with the rollout of Absolute Minimum Pricing.
In the last dozen or so years, Giant Eagle rolled out the upscale “Market District”stores, which echoed the Whole Foods boutique model, developed a social justice initiative “to stand up against racism and social injustice,” began the process of not providing shopping bags in order to combat climate change and became entangled in several very public battles over mask requirements and customers with disabilities during the pandemic.
Thanks to a combination of historic inflationary food costs and people overwhelmed with politics in everything they do, Giant Eagle’s market share has now slipped, going from 28.9 percent of the Pittsburgh metro area grocery market at the end of 2019 to 25.1 percent last year. The company is still the dominant grocer in the area, but competitors — like Walmart — are gaining.
Youngstown State University political science professor Paul Sracic says corporations deciding to get in the mud with politics is “just not a good business practice.” Companies used to be very careful not to offend half their market, “because that’s what you’re going to do in contemporary politics when you take a position. It doesn’t make any sense, from a competitive standpoint.”
“Does it really convince anybody? Do people change their politics because a grocery store made a statement about something? So, it has no positive effect, but it certainly has a negative effect on the bottom line,” he said.
Giant Eagle is synonymous with Pittsburgh, he added, pointing to the hilarious short films featuring Curt Wootton’s iconic character, a blue-collar dad from Pittsburgh who speaks with a thick Pittsburghese dialect. “Just watch those clips from Pittsburgh Dad: He always says ‘Yinz going dahn to Giant Iggles,’”
A lot of companies eventually lose their local character. “I think they think that they’re playing to an upscale audience by doing that, but maybe forgetting how price-sensitive people are, particularly now in a time of inflation, where people are going to go for that lowest price, that discount.”
Carly Smith, 25, said she doesn’t much pay attention to politics. As a single mother of two, she pays attention to her family budget. “I used to shop at Giant Eagle, but in the last couple of years, their costs aren’t just a few cents more, they are often two or three dollars more on things like lunchmeat,” she explained.
“So I go to Aldi’s and Shop and Save and B.J’s in Bridgeville. I’m not sure who Giant Eagle is catering to anymore, but it’s not working families. It’s a shame — there is something about carrying on a tradition and keeping a loyalty, but at the end of the day, prices are really high right now, and I have to think of my family.”
North Side native Salena Zito is a national political reporter for The Washington Examiner, a New York Post columnist and co-author of “The Great Revolt”: zito.salena@gmail.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.