The late Rabbi Jonathan Sacks, a world-renowned intellectual who served as Chief Rabbi of the United Kingdom, once wrote about the holiday of Tisha B’Av, which commemorates the destruction of both Temples in Jerusalem: “The Jews gave to the world this idea of time as a narrative of hope, which meant that what is lost can be regained, what is destroyed can be rebuilt, and what disappears may one day return.”

I think about this idea when I consider the trauma of knowing my husband went to work one Saturday morning four years ago, as he has done every Saturday during his more than thirty years as a rabbi, and could have been killed because an antisemitic gunman entered his synagogue bent on killing innocent Jews as they worshipped on the Sabbath. To counter his actions, our community needed to find an alternative narrative option.

Having someone harm you or try to harm you creates a sense of panic and fear and anxiety because of the loss of control that this incident generates; one way to try to restore that balance is through creating a narrative around the traumatic event, as trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy and narrative based trauma therapy do. These therapies help the client exert a level of control over the event and how to process it even if the event itself is out of their control.

I began this process of taking control of the narrative by helping to plan a trip to the Mother Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, SC, where nine Black worshippers were shot and killed in 2015. There, I met the pastor and several church members, both to learn from their experiences and to ally ourselves with other groups that had been similarly targeted. Our joining together created a shared action against hate, and specifically white supremacy, that countered the actions of both the shooter in Charleston and in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

Marching through city streets in the Martin Luther King, Jr., day parade in 2019 and teaching church members to sing “Behold how good and nice it is to sit and dwell with our brothers,” from Psalm 133, in Hebrew and English was beautiful and restoring — and part of creating our own narrative in response to what happened to us. On returning to Pittsburgh, I asked the members of our delegation from New Light Congregation and Rodman Street Missionary Baptist Church to write about the trip so we could send the reflections to our hosts in Charleston.

The other participants were not experienced writers, and I realized that it would be a great deal of work to edit all the essays. But once I thought about a collection of writings around the experience, I decided it would be meaningful to craft an anthology around the experiences of those in Squirrel Hill who had some connection to the shooting in order both to document and to reflect on our experiences. I spoke to Eric Lidji, the archivist of the Rauh Jewish Archive at the Heinz History Center, and he agreed this would be a valuable project. Together we recruited and edited the writing of journalists, academics, historians, rabbis, poets and memoirists who recounted their own understandings of the harm caused and the ways they reacted as individuals and communities.

Our anthology ends with the story of Linda Hurwitz, who was on her way to Tree of Life on October 27, 2018, to say kaddish for her only daughter, Karen, who had been murdered on that date in 1989. Ms. Hurwitz had to tell her Holocaust-survivor parents about the death of their oldest grandchild, an excruciating conversation. Their response to her was: You will get through this. That spirit and ability to have agency even over the most challenging of situations is how the community of Squirrel Hill has responded, and what I wanted to communicate to the world about our response in that book.

A hate-filled gunman killed eleven Jews here four years ago, but he could not harm our commitment to our religion and our resolve to continue to celebrate the Sabbath, to rejoice on Jewish holidays, and to study the Torah and Jewish texts regularly. That is where our true hope lies; that is the Jewish narrative of hope and optimism that counters the narrative of hate.

Something I’ve been doing to honor the memories of those who died here has been committing myself to studying a page of the Talmud each day. It makes me feel I am learning something of substance regularly and using my time well, working toward a goal and reaching it. It’s a way to keep my own story, and the story of the Jewish people, going forward, and to consistently renew myself by knowing I can learn something new each day.

Advertise with us

Recently, I studied this passage in the tractate of Ketubot 111b: “Rabbi Yoḥanan said: One who whitens his teeth to his friend by smiling at him is better than one who gives him milk to drink.” The text emphasizes that kindness and encouragement to another — that is, psychological sustenance — can be more even powerful than physical nourishment.

We participate in, and extend, the Jewish narrative of hope by creating and strengthening bonds of kindness with one another. To counter the shooter’s evil deeds, we need to do oppose them with a stronger force. It resolves nothing, for ourselves or for the world, to respond to violence with more killing.

This is why the Jewish tradition of our day opposes the death penalty, and why I continue to believe that the Department of Justice should accept the killer’s guilty plea in return to a sentence of life without parole.

Holding a trial that will call attention to the hateful ideas of an evil person, as well as graphic evidence of the horror he wrought, will not do anything to aid in healing or building a narrative of hope. We hope Pittsburgh will be able to build that hopeful narrative by continuing with the rebuilding of our lives, with the shooter in jail for life and without a trial.

Our responsibility is to do the opposite of what the shooter did. Where he sowed hatred and fear, the rest of us need to live out a narrative of hope: gathering to study and pray and perform deeds of kindness that enhance life rather than diminish it. That is how we achieve a sense of hopefulness, a way to look to a future where better things are possible.

Beth Kissileff is co-editor of “Bound in the Bond of Life: Pittsburgh Writers Respond to the Tree of Life Tragedy” and the author of the novel “Questioning Return.”