Sitting opposite Pittsburgh’s exquisitely massed and proportioned skyline, Grandview Avenue on Mt. Washington has the potential to be not merely the most beautiful street in Pittsburgh, but the greatest street in America.
In a “Big Idea” editorial in December, the Editorial Board correctly described the “mystery” of Grandview Avenue: “that the precipice of one of the great urban vistas of the world is populated largely by low-rise residences — including many single-family homes — a school, a library and a good deal of vacant land.”
The editors recommended a new, iconic skyscraper on the ridge line and a gondola connection to downtown. Unfortunately, these interventions will not deliver a great street.
A problem for Grandview
Mt. Washington does not lack for housing, and there is already at least one skyscraper, the Trimont, which was once supposed to be iconic and currently has vacancy. Building another could be a colossal folly.
This is not a problem for architecture to solve. It’s a public realm problem. In his book “Great Streets,” urban planner Allen Jacob’s defines criteria for great streets, saying “First and foremost, a great street should help make a community: should facilitate people acting and interacting to achieve in concert what they might not achieve alone.”
Jacobs further argues, “The best streets encourage participation. People stop to talk or maybe they sit and watch, as passive participants, taking in what the street has to offer.”
There are a wide range of interventions from the mundane to the extraordinary that could transform Grandview Avenue into the greatest street in America.
First, the basics:
Invest in streetscape improvements including additional lighting with character (add string lights in between the lampposts), add more seating options along the street, including some with cover (without obscuring the view), re-pave the street with specialty paving and eliminate the sidewalk curb (this will create a pedestrian-oriented shared space for cars and people), replace the ineffective speed bumps (the dirt bikes and motorcycles use as jumps!) with chicanes (serpentine bulb outs), and add hanging baskets to create a sense of enclosure.
Changes for Grandview
Next, targeted interventions:
Right now, there’s a rare opportunity to re-develop the parcel adjacent to the beautiful Carnegie library and create an amenity node. The church has been vacant and for sale for years.
There are no outdoor dining options opposite the overlooks. How is there nowhere to sit in the sunshine under an umbrella with a coffee or a glass of wine on this stretch of Grandview?
All of the neighborhood’s playgrounds are blocks (hilly blocks) back off of Grandview. A new playground here or alternatively, a mini playground on the site of the parklet opposite the Mon Incline and at the entrance to Shiloh Street would not only be a community amenity but would encourage families who visit the Mount to take in the view to stay (and to go to the restaurants on Shiloh or Bingham Streets for ice cream, coffee, or lunch).
The parcel adjacent to the Mon Incline on Grandview and Sycamore Streets is large and has a striking view. If the city built a playground on the church parcel, this site could be a candidate for the Editor’s mixed use development.
It would especially add to the street’s vibrancy if it includes a food hall with outdoor dining options. Or perhaps it could include a large outdoor roller rink. Imagine skating in the summertime with Pittsburgh’s skyline as a backdrop.
The parklets at the entrance to Shiloh Street and at the end of Shiloh Street (Fireman’s Park) are crucial anchors at both ends of Shiloh. The parklet at Grandview and Shiloh, if not a new mini-playground, should be designed to pull visitors down Shiloh Street. It could have well designed seating options and robust plantings.
Fireman’s Park at the terminus of Shiloh Street could have a water feature, something that nods to the adjacent fire station and offers a refreshing respite in hot weather. It could also be a fountain-splash pad to make it more interactive.
The parcel across from Fireman’s Park, including the turret that is the visual terminus of Shiloh Street, once home to a famous neighborhood bakery, includes several buildings currently for sale. Combined with the other two strategically located parcels, these development opportunities represent a real opportunity to create a connected public realm.
Ideas for Grandview
Finally, more bold ideas:
The overlooks are charming but antiquated. A boardwalk would extend the sidewalk, offer more and diverse options for seating, and opportunities for stands to sell refreshments.
The Editors proposed a gondola connection to Downtown, but a bolder plan would include three layers of development, the inclines, an installation on the face of Mount Washington, and a gondola overhead. Such an installation could be terraced gardens and steps, or a massive climbing wall, or a mountain bike trail.
Projects Pittsburgh should look to for inspiration include:
Southern Ridges in Singapore is a six-mile tree-top level boardwalk (iconic bridges included) that connects five parks. Pittsburgh is the City of Bridges after all!
Rothschild Boulevard in Tel Aviv and Las Ramblas in Barcelona, both offer strong examples of streets with stands or kiosks offering refreshments and gathering spots, street art, and music
The Baháʼí Terraces in Haifa include terraced gardens with steps connecting downtown Haifa and the port to Mount Carmel with a gondola overhead. Haifa also has an underground incline — imagine that!
A street can be great with or without great buildings (although they do help). Great streets are like giant outdoor rooms where people can take in society while walking, talking, eating and playing. A single new skyscraper will stick up like an ugly nail on the ridge line. Enjoy the flawless view of the buildings opposite and invest in making America’s greatest street instead.
Sunny Menozzi Peterson is an urban planner and the owner of Three Elephants Studio in Pittsburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.