America is embroiled in yet another war with a country that it knows little about. Time and again, in Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, and now Iran, America has ignored the lessons of history — especially the lessons of Napoleon’s 1807 invasion of Spain.
A war American military leaders know about, because the Army’s 2006 Counterinsurgency Manual described it and showed how Napoleon’s lack of knowledge of the nation he was invading undermined his military efforts.
Napoleon makes a mistake
In 1807, flush with hubris from his military domination of the rest of Europe, Napoleon promptly invaded Spain and defeated the nation’s regular army. He expected Spain to accept French control as had other European nations. He did not understand the country.
Instead, an unanticipated fanatical nationalism of church and state birthed a vicious guerrilla war. The term “guerrilla” means “little war.”
Guerrillas infested the countryside, confining French troops to towns and outposts. They attacked isolated outposts. They sneaked into French camps at night, quietly killing soldiers with the knife and garrote.
As the Manual observes, the Spanish Guerrilla War lasted nearly six years and tied down about three-fifths of all of Napoleon’s forces. The Manual states, “It was the beginning of the end for Napoleon. At the theatre level, a complete understanding of the problem and a campaign design that allowed the counterinsurgency force to learn and adapt was lacking.”
Among other militarily harmful results for the French, with so many French troops needed in Spain, the Duke of Wellington was able to slowly advance northward in Portugal. A few years later, this added pressure on Napoleon’s strategic rear after his doomed 1812 invasion of Russia.
Three big failures
The year 2006, when the Manual was published was 33 years after the nation’s ignominious abandonment of South Vietnam. That year gave two more examples of America’s failure to understand what it was getting into.
In Iraq, the U.S. was in the middle of the still vicious Iraqi insurgency, which America again had failed to anticipate.
In Afghanistan, the nation was bogged down fighting another insurgency. The war had begun with a just need to destroy the terrorists who were attacking America. But with little understanding of that country, America had neither the will for, nor the understanding of the need for, dogged, constant pursuit of the Taliban after they had been cleared from the towns and countryside.
As a result, the Taliban came back. This, along with the unanticipated weakness of the Afghan Army that America had created, led to yet another embarrassing and costly defeat.
Two big successes
America had not always been so bad at war. It did successfully vanquish and suitably change the ways of Japan and West Germany following World War II. World War II offers five lessons on when to risk the horror of war and how to conduct it.
First, there must be a powerful enemy’s plainly imminent or actual existential attack on America or a nation with whom America has a Senate ratified defense treaty.
Second, the war aim for unconditional surrender must be clear, clearly justified, and the cost of blood and treasure to achieve it wholly supported by the American people throughout the war.
Third, the enemy must be thoroughly and permanently vanquished before and after its surrender.
Fourth, America must bear the heavy burden and cost of maintaining its military and other necessary personnel in the defeated nation for the time it takes to change the objectionable cherished traditions and culture of the defeated nation.
Fifth, this last step requires a thorough understanding of that culture and those traditions before or as soon as possible after hostilities begin and before working to change them.
The lessons for America
As Spain, Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan demonstrated, before America decides whether or not its national interest justifies war against an enemy that has not committed such an existential attack, or is not imminently poised to do so, the culture, religions, demography, motivations, history and languages of the opponent must be thoroughly understood.
With this understanding, the nation can better assess the odds of being able to vanquish this enemy and change its ways, what the cost in blood and treasure will be, the time it will take, whether the American people will support the war for its duration, and whether America’s national interest outweighs unfavorable odds.
If this informed assessment has not been done or indicates the risk of a Spain or Vietnam is too high, war should not be chosen. If, after this assessment, war is chosen, the military should have a better understanding of what it will face and the appropriate strategy and tactics to be used.
Two new wars, one disastrous
None of this appears to have been done before America, swelled with hubris, attacked Venezuela and Iran.
America so far has lucked out on the former, but, as Napoleon was in Spain, America and Israel are now faced with a fanatical nationalism of religion and state in a large and perhaps growing segment of the Iranian population. Unless there is a diplomatic breakthrough, ground troops appear necessary to secure the war aim that Iran will never have a nuclear bomb.
The ultimate cost in blood and treasure of using ground troops in this war will be appalling. Iran has and will take advantage of ignorance of them and of what they are capable.
If only America’s leaders knew more history — or paid attention to their own Counterinsurgency Manual.
Daniel O. Jamison, a retired attorney, is the author of the forthcoming book “The Birth of Jim Crow: Racism, Reconstruction and the Pivotal Supreme Court Cases of 1857-1908.” His previous article was “Has humanity already lost control of AI? Are we doomed?”.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.