Prior to the financial crisis of 2008, the United States was still largely defined by two dominant parties, with independents forming a substantial — but less influential — third group. In the years that followed the crisis, trust in government fell sharply, as documented by Pew Research Center, and independents grew not just in number, but in political relevance.

In 2011, more Americans identified as independents than with either major political party. According to Gallup, roughly 40% of Americans began identifying as independents around that time — surpassing both Democrats and Republicans individually — and that share has remained elevated ever since.

Tribal tensions

Political tribalism is not new. Tensions escalated during the Clinton administration, culminating in the United States federal government shutdowns of 1995 and 1996. But gridlock became more entrenched during the Obama years, particularly with the rise of the Tea Party.

Since 2010, government shutdowns and near-shutdown crises have become more frequent and more normalized as negotiating tools, rather than rare breakdowns in governance.

Advertise with us

At the same time, partisan animosity has reached historic levels. In recent years, roughly eight in 10 Americans in both parties report viewing the opposing party unfavorably, according to Pew.

That level of distrust makes compromise politically risky, even when it is broadly popular. I’ve had more than a few conversations with voters who openly admit they don’t like their own party’s candidate, but still can’t imagine voting for the other side.

And yet, many Americans still say they want cooperation. The disconnect lies in who actually participates in the elections that matter most.

The disconnect

Primary elections — where candidates are selected — are dominated by a relatively small share of voters. Turnout is often below 30% of eligible voters, and frequently much lower in non-presidential years.

That means a narrow, highly motivated segment of the electorate has an outsized influence on who ultimately appears on the general election ballot. As a result, political success is too often defined by media performance rather than governing performance.

Advertise with us

The incentives are clear. Candidates who appeal to the most engaged primary voters are rewarded, while those who prioritize broad consensus often struggle to advance. It is no surprise, then, that many Americans feel they are choosing the “lesser of two evils.” That’s a sentiment that consistently shows up in national polling.

So where does the solution lie?

One solution is structural: open primaries. If all voters, including independent, could participate in primary elections, candidates would need to appeal to a broader electorate.

Some states that have adopted more inclusive systems have seen candidates build wider coalitions, though results vary. Expanding participation would, at a minimum, change the incentives.

However, implementing open primaries nationwide would require political will from the very parties that benefit from the current system.

Advertise with us

The best answer

That leaves a second, more immediate path: participation. If more voters — particularly moderates and independents who lean toward one party — registered accordingly and voted in primaries, they could meaningfully influence candidate selection. Today, too many of those elections are decided by too few people.

The framers of the Constitution warned about the dangers of factionalism. In the 10th Federalist Paper, James Madison described how organized factions could prioritize their own interests over the common good. The danger they were concerned about is clearly visible in today’s political environment.

In response, many Americans have disengaged from party politics altogether. But disengagement does not change outcomes. Participation does.

If voters want more moderate, more capable leadership — leaders willing to govern rather than posture — they need to shape the system where candidates are actually chosen.

Bringing moderation back to American politics will not happen until moderates return to the process — and that begins not in November, but in the primaries.

Michael Manchester is the founder of Hearthstone Advisory in St. Augustine, Fl.